[feeler]

Originally Posted by Egg

The video proves my point. As the sun rises, the shadows move. Just like I showed you. Add to this its three days later and the sun rises a little later each day, and yes, thanks for proving my point for me.

Sun comes up, shadows move, shadow sinks.

Egg, You expect to see that 20 foot wide shadow (on Tribeca Grand Hotel) on Sep 11, but not on Sep 14?

Applying your logic, the shadow on the ATT building (the "Big Brown") would be 20 foot away on Sep 14.

FOR YOUR REFERENCE:

The time doesn't matter, or the date.

What matters is that the shadow on the ATT building is the same as seen in the Naudet clip. Then we look for the impossible shadow. And there it is. I still do not know how this shadow could be cast, as the shadow on the ATT building clearly indicates that the light is coming from left of shot, and the "impossible shadow" seems as if it can only be cast by the ATT building when light is coming from bottom of shot. That shadow was not the only problem I had with that footage, but it was what I battled with, and at present Rosalee has provided video that appears to show that the two shadows are not impossible together. I am puzzled but have to accept this. I will add Rosalee's clip to my Naudet page, and maybe list the other problems that I had with the footage.
by John Gault

___