What is the motive behind Naudets' fake video?

[Egg]

Originally Posted by Egg

Look - here is the building that would of cast the shadow that moves. It even fits the shape of the shadow thrown in your image. It even is in line of direct shadow casting ability - look on google street view - some thing that the video (airy fairy or what ever its name is ) never did.

The shadow fits the building perfectly. It would throw a different shadow due to its unusual shape. The shape is the same.

[feeler]

Originally Posted by Egg

The shadow fits the building perfectly. It would throw a different shadow due to its unusual shape. The shape is the same.

Egg, here's a second opinion (from YougeneDebs) I came across after I started this thread.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4zO3k0r9WI

YougeneDebs (3 weeks ago)

The shadows in question [by coffinman] are on the Tribeca Grand Hotel, at Church and Walker, the next block down from the big brown building, the Telegraph building.

The shadows on the brown building can be used as a reference set for judging the shadows on the Hotel.