+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 21 to 40 of 44

Thread: Is gold precious?

  1. Link to Post #21
    Avalon Member eaglespirit's Avatar
    Join Date
    8th November 2010
    Posts
    2,720
    Thanks
    50,159
    Thanked 25,180 times in 2,653 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Just adding a 'nugget' here.
    Gold and ruby and quartz in a conch shell create a 'higher' transmitter/connector...
    as was revealed to Lorae, a friend, years ago.
    Medicine Wheels are an integral part of my journey...as I built them as connectors of gratitude wherever I traveled in the hills and mountains and such places as I was drawn.
    Gold mining areas were nearby to many of them I created...and an integral part of the local history. Interesting.
    ......

    Next, my Spirit Teachers told me to build a medicine wheel near a vortex on our ranch. I told them that I knew nothing about Indian religion and wouldn't know where to start. Ignoring my complaints and arguments, they told me to get rocks from all four vortices of the Return Focus Triangle to place at the four compass points of the wheel. Next I was told to get a conch shell for the center, putting in it a small gold nugget, a quartz crystal and a ruby (which makes laser light in both worlds). That did it. I told them that I couldn't get a conch shell, and a ruby was out of the question. However, a few days later, as I wandered through a second-hand shop, the owner's daughter came in. She was carrying a large conch shell and said, "What shall we do with this?" Of course I bought it.

    Listening to my Teachers for each step, I put this medicine wheel together. I bought a teensy-tiny ruby for the conch shell. Mount Shasta rocks made up the south points of the wheel, Crater Lake the north, Mount Ashland the east, and serpentine from Eight Dollar Mountain on the west corner, the Point of Wisdom and Power facing the East. In the center of the wheel, extending to the circumference and using rocks from each of the four vortices for each spoke (Eight Dollar rocks for the west, Shasta for the south, Crater Lake for the East and Mt. Ashland for the north), I oriented a cross to the four compass points. In the very center of this cross went the conch shell with gold, crystal and ruby touching each other in the cut part. By putting this wheel close to my home, I brought forth enormous energies into my life. Medicine wheels, by their very nature, probably shouldn't be close to places of habitation.


    http://unveiling.fr.yuku.com/topic/62

  2. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to eaglespirit For This Post:

    Calz (17th December 2012), DeDukshyn (18th December 2012), Marianne (17th December 2012), PurpleLama (17th December 2012), Shade (17th December 2012), ThePythonicCow (17th December 2012)

  3. Link to Post #22
    Brazil Avalon Retired Member
    Join Date
    28th June 2011
    Location
    Belo Horizonte, Brazil
    Age
    40
    Posts
    3,857
    Thanks
    18,436
    Thanked 24,127 times in 3,536 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Hey folks,

    Well, despite gold being a very good conductor and very useful to nowadays high-end electronic components, I couldnīt care less about it.

    People keep talking about gold being a very good alternative currency in times of crisis, which is not accurate at all.

    There are countless reports of people, during the World Wars, carrying a bag full of gold and silver to farms and leaving with nothing but a very expensive bag of vegetables that wouldnīt last for one week.

    In times of serious crisis, useful items are much more valuable for trading than gold.

    Raf.

  4. The Following 9 Users Say Thank You to RMorgan For This Post:

    aranuk (17th December 2012), chancy (17th December 2012), Cjay (20th December 2012), Davidallany (17th December 2012), eaglespirit (17th December 2012), jagman (17th December 2012), kanishk (25th February 2013), seko (17th December 2012), ThePythonicCow (17th December 2012)

  5. Link to Post #23
    Avalon Member Maia Gabrial's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th April 2011
    Location
    On the planet Sophia
    Age
    71
    Posts
    4,605
    Thanks
    15,747
    Thanked 17,151 times in 3,856 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote So, I wonder, just how much gold is there, as well as the related question, what's a good "safe harbor" for ones savings, during a major transition in the monetary system?
    IMO we should get away from a monetary system altogether. Everything should be free. The Andromedans wonder why we have to pay to live on our own planet.
    I'm thinking that what if gold is only important to the uberwealthy and not the rest of us? What if they can't buy our products and services with their gold if it means nothing to us? Wouldn't that take control away from THEM and give it to us? Afterall, aren't we the ones who make this world go round? The uberrich aren't as productive as they'd like us to believe anyway. In fact, if we're going to think "useless eaters" here, they fit that bill perfectly. I know I can survive without them.

    And another thing to consider is if "life as we have KNOWN it will ge changed" then maybe we, as an entire planet can come up with a system that can never be corrupted or highjacked again by the few.

    Paul, I know you meant for this thread to share ideas on how to protect one's hard earned savings and I might have taken it off track with my post. Sorry.... I'm one person who is so fed up with the status quo. I want to see it all go. I want to see everything free so that no one goes without, or manipulated by TPTW for nefarious agendas. Sick and tired of them and their ways....

    Gold should be a pretty, shiny metal good for jewelry and artistry. Nothing else.... imo....

  6. The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to Maia Gabrial For This Post:

    chancy (17th December 2012), eaglespirit (17th December 2012), jagman (17th December 2012), TargeT (17th December 2012), ThePythonicCow (17th December 2012)

  7. Link to Post #24
    Avalon Member
    Join Date
    17th December 2010
    Location
    Alberta - Canada
    Posts
    774
    Thanks
    907
    Thanked 4,381 times in 699 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by Paul (here)
    Quote Posted by chancy (here)
    Is gold precious?

    I came across another piece of information regarding gold that seems to continue to make a case that gold is worthless:

    You can read the full paragraphs in Bill Ryan's post or Jagmans post. Basically William Rutledge said the following and I quote:
    ...

    Again I say you can't eat it! It's worthless.....
    chancy
    I think you quoted the same material I quoted in the opening post of this thread .

    I would also suggest that not all that's valuable is edible (unless I suppose one is about to starve to death.)
    Hello Paul: I think you missed my point! No one including me ever said that gold or anything else has to be edible to be valuable. My point was about your point and I quote: "Is Gold Precious?"
    I say it's not for many factors and one of those being you can't eat it. IF and maybe when the financial system of today goes into the tank people think that gold is going to save them. I say absolutely not! I simply used the analogy that you can't eat it because food will be a premium when the financial system is in ruins. You won't be able to give gold away because there will be no value to it.
    People put too much emphasis on gold. It's more over rated than diamonds.
    chancy

  8. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to chancy For This Post:

    eaglespirit (17th December 2012), RMorgan (17th December 2012), ThePythonicCow (17th December 2012)

  9. Link to Post #25
    United States Administrator ThePythonicCow's Avatar
    Join Date
    4th January 2011
    Location
    North Texas
    Language
    English
    Age
    76
    Posts
    28,613
    Thanks
    30,530
    Thanked 138,602 times in 21,522 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by Maia Gabrial (here)
    Paul, I know you meant for this thread to share ideas on how to protect one's hard earned savings and I might have taken it off track with my post. Sorry.... I'm one person who is so fed up with the status quo. I want to see it all go. I want to see everything free so that no one goes without, or manipulated by TPTW for nefarious agendas. Sick and tired of them and their ways....
    That's OK ... you and 7 billion other humans as well as countless other living beings on this planet have damn good reasons to be sick and tired of all this crap .
    My quite dormant website: pauljackson.us

  10. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to ThePythonicCow For This Post:

    eaglespirit (17th December 2012), risveglio (17th December 2012)

  11. Link to Post #26
    United States Administrator ThePythonicCow's Avatar
    Join Date
    4th January 2011
    Location
    North Texas
    Language
    English
    Age
    76
    Posts
    28,613
    Thanks
    30,530
    Thanked 138,602 times in 21,522 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by araucaria (here)
    On another thread a while back, there was mention of the transmutation of gold being a reality, and if so, the scarcity paradigm would no longer be applicable.
    That (gold no longer being scarce) might depend on the amount of energy required for such transmutations, and whether that energy was still controlled under a scarcity paradigm.
    My quite dormant website: pauljackson.us

  12. The Following User Says Thank You to ThePythonicCow For This Post:

    eaglespirit (17th December 2012)

  13. Link to Post #27
    France Avalon Member araucaria's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th January 2011
    Posts
    5,400
    Thanks
    12,061
    Thanked 30,977 times in 5,003 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by Paul (here)
    Quote Posted by araucaria (here)
    On another thread a while back, there was mention of the transmutation of gold being a reality, and if so, the scarcity paradigm would no longer be applicable.
    That (gold no longer being scarce) might depend on the amount of energy required for such transmutations, and whether that energy was still controlled under a scarcity paradigm.
    Who would care how much energy was involved in terms of say coal or human labour, if the end result was obtained?

    I certainly don't count my hours of effort in achieving my own version of gold.


  14. The Following User Says Thank You to araucaria For This Post:

    eaglespirit (17th December 2012)

  15. Link to Post #28
    United States Avalon Member Chip's Avatar
    Join Date
    12th August 2012
    Location
    Owasso, Ok
    Language
    English
    Age
    55
    Posts
    486
    Thanks
    9,000
    Thanked 3,497 times in 466 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    I have always been fascinated with Gold.
    As a young bush pilot in Alaska I can recall my first flight picking up some prospectors and taking them to Anchorage. We carried a scale in the door pocket that I never used and finally figured out that it was used to weigh gold to pay for the flight.
    Being a "rock hound" from my youth I was immediately hooked.
    I now spend my time as a hobby to find said treasure. I am often asked "where do you sell your gold" . I don't.
    It does not have any monetary meaning to me (I can say this in deep honesty) .
    Gold for me is a reminder.
    It represents the alchemical perfection of matter. It is to me a reminder of who I am or what I am capable of becoming.
    Every nugget that I find with my metal detector has a precious story. And when I am out in nature in the search, where I find the deeper meanings to life. So much so that it actually has increased my odds of finding it.
    I've learned more from nature in this process than from any "sage" or "guru" .
    So what is gold?

  16. Link to Post #29
    United States On Sabbatical
    Join Date
    30th June 2011
    Location
    The Seat of Corruption
    Age
    44
    Posts
    9,177
    Thanks
    25,610
    Thanked 53,662 times in 8,694 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by Cjay (here)
    Quote Posted by TargeT (here)
    As to gold : it's not really used industrially
    Just about every computer uses gold in some of the electrical contacts because gold does not corrode and it is a very good conductor. This is the main reason why recycling obsolete computers became such a big business.
    OH I'm very familiar with this fact, I just did not realize how much was used (each mother board has only trace amounts).

    apparently those traces add up:
    Quote Principally used in jewelry, gold (chemical symbol Au) is also used generally in manufacturing (and by the electronics and computer industries in particular) due to its excellent thermal and electrical conductivity, resistance to oxidation, and inalterability. The computer industry uses several hundred tons (318 tons in 2003, for example) of the element every year.
    The precious metal is found in almost all computer components--processors, motherboards, extension cards, memory DIMMs, and so on. Of course, the amounts used in each part are infinitesimal. But with the price of gold skyrocketing in recent years, it’s becoming more and more economically-viable to recover gold from old electronic and computer components than to mine it. That’s why specialized companies have sprung up to do just that.
    http://www.tomshardware.com/pictures...chemistry.html
    Hard times create strong men, Strong men create good times, Good times create weak men, Weak men create hard times.
    Where are you?

  17. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to TargeT For This Post:

    Cjay (20th December 2012), ThePythonicCow (18th December 2012)

  18. Link to Post #30
    Ecuador Avalon Member Davidallany's Avatar
    Join Date
    21st February 2011
    Location
    Loja
    Language
    English
    Age
    50
    Posts
    1,970
    Thanks
    7,564
    Thanked 6,056 times in 1,577 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Gold is associated with mystical powers. I have personally seen this as well as read about it afterwards in a book called unplugging the patriarchy. I haven't been able to find out why, so far. All that I know is that once a person reaches a certain mystical stage, that person will be able to see golden light or mist, exactly like the colour of real gold.

  19. The Following User Says Thank You to Davidallany For This Post:

    ThePythonicCow (18th December 2012)

  20. Link to Post #31
    Australia Avalon Member Anchor's Avatar
    Join Date
    10th February 2010
    Location
    NSW, Australia
    Language
    English
    Age
    60
    Posts
    4,601
    Thanks
    11,212
    Thanked 25,832 times in 3,731 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    When forged onto one ring to rule them all, it becomes very precious!

    I know, I saw it in a film.
    -- Let the truth be known by all, let the truth be known by all, let the truth be known by all --

  21. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to Anchor For This Post:

    Jean-Marie (24th December 2012), TargeT (19th December 2012), ThePythonicCow (18th December 2012), thunder24 (18th December 2012)

  22. Link to Post #32
    Avalon Member Tesseract's Avatar
    Join Date
    19th October 2012
    Posts
    834
    Thanks
    1,740
    Thanked 3,393 times in 744 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    About gold:

    As far as I know there is no evidence that gold is the most common, let’s say ‘element’, in the universe, I believe hydrogen has that honour. Like all elements of greater atomic number than iron, gold is produced by the fusing of nuclei in particularly large stars that reach the supernova stage. There are probably some planets out there that are extremely gold rich, but Earth isn’t one of them. We are blessed with a lot of silicon though, which is a handy fact to remember when negotiating the price of breast implants with your plastic surgeon. At the risk of going off on (another) tangent, the most common ‘substance’ in the universe is actually the so called dark matter, which is theorized to exist but which we have not directly observed.

    The alchemists believed gold to be the ultimate of all metals, to which all other ‘base’ metals had the potential to become. To the alchemists gold was almost the pinnacle of perfection, the pinnacle being the philosopher’s stone. Mercury, due to its ability to dissolve other metals, was an important substance in alchemical procedures. Bizarrely, and poetically, long after the alchemists had been deemed to be chasing a wild goose with their mercury studies, mercury was found to transmutate into gold by way of nuclear decay.

    Many a gold ‘expert’ in the economics area will tell you gold actually has no intrinsic value. This is garbage – utterly. The usefulness of gold is fundamental to its value, and I don’t understand why people don’t realise this. Any metal object made from a gold, gold alloy, or other precious metal will not suffer from corrosion – just think of the possibilities. Gold also has a tremendous density too – it would find use as ships’ ballast, fishing sinkers, divers weights and so on if it weren’t so rare.

    Regarding not being able to eat gold – think again. Gold leaf is used to garnish dishes and is consumed with the dish. Some folks also find the urge to drink aqueous gold dispersions. Zero calories yet should make you gain weight. Interesting idea that, new age people also used to drink uranium solutions – until their bones crumbled away and their jaws fell off.

    Another interesting aspect of gold is that it has the highest formal potential in the electrochemical series, making it extremely resistant to electrochemical corrosion. I’m sure you could design a nice gold based battery to capitalise on its high formal potential. In fact, high energy prototype lithium batteries work better with gold – but it’s too expensive to be practical. Gold has excellent electrical conductivity and would also presumably be a good radiation blocker. And the other precious metals (especially Pt and Pd) are even more useful than gold.

    Regarding investment, the fact is that we live in a plutocracy and not a technocracy, and therefore the price of gold is mostly set by institutional traders, government capitalists and central banks – industrial demand has a relatively small influence. To invest in gold is to predict what the plutocrats will do next. The epic inflation people fear monger about in the US won’t happen anytime soon because of the weak economy, and a lot of the stimulus money is diluting overseas markets, not the US. Therefore your fiat waste-paper is probably safe for a while yet.
    Last edited by Tesseract; 18th December 2012 at 03:57. Reason: typo

  23. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Tesseract For This Post:

    RMorgan (18th December 2012), sdv (18th December 2012), ThePythonicCow (18th December 2012)

  24. Link to Post #33
    India Avalon Member
    Join Date
    24th September 2011
    Location
    Pune, India.
    Posts
    527
    Thanks
    9,098
    Thanked 2,534 times in 476 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Many people are making ORMUS gold and many other are extracting ORMUS elements from already available ormus in nature. Is it possible to convert ceramic ORMUS gold into normal metallic form again?

    Because in some videos made by people who sell ormus gold talk about handling of their ormus gold powder/liquid, so that it may not convert back into gold again.

    And also I found behavior of ormus element, discussed in David Hudsons experience about finding out about ORMUS. Many guys who are extracting ormus and making ormus are not talking about or demonstrating other physical properties that can be found about ormus, because I think if they are doing those complicated chemical extracting and conversion techniques then they also would have done those other experiments {=which are experienced by David Hudson while discovering about ormus} for their own curiosity.

  25. Link to Post #34
    United States Avalon Member kaon's Avatar
    Join Date
    21st November 2012
    Age
    62
    Posts
    215
    Thanks
    454
    Thanked 768 times in 180 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    I didn't realize that gold was in such abundance in the universe. I find that interesting. It also makes me wonder what would happen if we could harvest gold from space. Granted it may not be cost effective yet, but some day it may.
    I am not sure how precious it would be if we had a few hundred tons of it delivered to us and what economic impact it would have if the value plummeted. Then what?

    When will we progress past the point of rocks determining wealth?
    Ask not what Avalon can do for you, but what you can do for Avalon.

  26. Link to Post #35
    United States Avalon Member GlassSteagallfan's Avatar
    Join Date
    21st January 2011
    Location
    The Berkshires
    Posts
    1,218
    Thanks
    2,248
    Thanked 4,532 times in 987 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by araucaria (here)
    On another thread a while back, there was mention of the transmutation of gold being a reality, and if so, the scarcity paradigm would no longer be applicable.
    Here's an article dated 7 Oct 2012 on PressTV:

    Iranian researcher creates 24-carat gold in lab
    http://www.presstv.ir/detail/2012/10...ate-pure-gold/

    Iranian researcher Kazem Kashefi along with his American colleague has created gold in Michigan State University using bacteria in a way called ‘microbial alchemy.’

    Kashefi and Adam Brown used a special type of bacterium to turn liquid gold into more valuable 24-karat gold.

    They reported that the bacteria Cupriavidus metallidurans is capable of resisting the toxic effects of gold chloride, and can transform large concentrations of the substance into 24-karat gold, Science Daily reports.

    “Microbial alchemy is what we are doing, transforming gold from something that has no value into a solid, precious metal that is valuable," said the assistant professor of microbiology and molecular genetics Kazem Kashefi.

    Researchers proved the point with their art installation ‘The Great Work for the Metal Lover,’ in which colonies of the hardy bacteria were fed with massive doses of gold chloride. In about a week, the bacteria produced a gold nugget.

    Their artwork contains a portable laboratory made of 24-karat gold-plated hardware, a glass bioreactor and the bacteria, a combination that produces gold in front of the audience.

    "This is neo-alchemy. Every part, every detail of the project is a cross between modern microbiology and alchemy," said the associate professor of electronic art and intermedia, Adam Brown.

    “Science tries to explain the phenomenological world. As an artist, I'm trying to create a phenomenon. Art has the ability to push scientific inquiry," he added.

    FGP/PKH

  27. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to GlassSteagallfan For This Post:

    araucaria (24th December 2012), TargeT (24th December 2012)

  28. Link to Post #36
    Avalon Member SKAWF's Avatar
    Join Date
    7th January 2011
    Location
    london
    Posts
    732
    Thanks
    2,928
    Thanked 3,384 times in 633 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    in isolation, gold is worthless.

    you cant eat it....
    i doubt you could knock a nail into a piece of wood with it

    but in relation to other metals, it has qualities which give it a higher value.

    maliablilty, conductivity, and it doesnt rust.

    and whether or not the price is rigged, or the amount in circulation is controlled,
    there is a human aspect to the value of commodities,
    which is that things are only worth...... what people are willing to pay

    its humans that apply the value to it.

    but i wouldnt say gold was precious...
    its too widely circulated to have that term applied to it imo.

    i would term it a high value commodity.
    when i went there nothing happened!, i was bored out of my mind..................in the Twilight Zone.

  29. The Following User Says Thank You to SKAWF For This Post:

    Seikou-Kishi (24th December 2012)

  30. Link to Post #37
    Avalon Member Seikou-Kishi's Avatar
    Join Date
    23rd November 2010
    Location
    Middanġeard
    Posts
    2,194
    Thanks
    2,819
    Thanked 5,331 times in 1,296 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by SKAWF (here)
    in isolation, gold is worthless.

    you cant eat it....
    i doubt you could knock a nail into a piece of wood with it

    but in relation to other metals, it has qualities which give it a higher value.

    maliablilty, conductivity, and it doesnt rust.

    and whether or not the price is rigged, or the amount in circulation is controlled,
    there is a human aspect to the value of commodities,
    which is that things are only worth...... what people are willing to pay

    its humans that apply the value to it.

    but i wouldnt say gold was precious...
    its too widely circulated to have that term applied to it imo.

    i would term it a high value commodity.
    In isolation, everything is worthless. Worth is in the general and literal sense a value judgement, and as such requires both a valued thing and valuer (which may be the same). Things valued for pecuniary or utilitarian purposes also have the purpose, all being strictly means to ends as opposed to those things the value of which is held to be inherent (people, for example). In this respect, gold isn't and probably never will have any value at all as food but for the various properties you note. Value therefore changes according to the needs of the moment. Though we would all hold food, water and air to be intrinsically more precious and vital to human life, if our concern is, for example, creating more electrically-conducive wiring, we would find a waldorf salad pretty unappealing.

    Is gold precious? I would say so, providing those two requirements are met: that it has a "needer" and a purpose for which it is needed. We can consider the preciousness of a thing in relation to those things which would fulfil the same function. If it scores better for electrical conductivity than copper (it does), then for purposes of electrical conductivity, gold will always have a baseline value higher than copper.

    It sounds like a good argument to say that if there is a lot of something in circulation, it's value must be lowered by that fact, but the high circulation of anything cannot be held to be a prerequisite of preciousness; oxygen is all over the place.

  31. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Seikou-Kishi For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (24th December 2012), SKAWF (24th December 2012), TargeT (24th December 2012)

  32. Link to Post #38
    United States On Sabbatical
    Join Date
    30th June 2011
    Location
    The Seat of Corruption
    Age
    44
    Posts
    9,177
    Thanks
    25,610
    Thanked 53,662 times in 8,694 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by TargeT (here)
    I watched silver go from it's almost seemingly set-in-stone price of $4/oz to $49/oz (briefly), I found seemingly very good evidence of price suppression & predicted that silver would be up in the 100+/oz price by now due to law suits that were being brought against JP morgan et al.

    However it has since slipped from its high of 49 to 32 (or so) and held pretty steady there, I was looking at silver as an investment, not a wealth store, there are a lot of really good reasons for silver to be up over 100 /oz right now but it's just not happening, I do not see it as "risky" since I don't think the price will fall, but I don't see it as a "get rich" move like I use to. I think I fatigued myself on the topic..

    the whole thing is kind of funny, I made a lot of other people money with my research but never purchased silver myself... haha

    I used to check this page:
    http://www.kitco.com/charts/livesilver.html
    so much that I would dream about it... haha
    according to HalfPastHuman silver will (in the next 3 weeks or so) spike to 40-50 per oz, then drop back again to around 30/oz

    This is suppose to signal the end of silver manipulation, silver will then climb to it's traditional 1:20 ratio (gold:silver) or possibly higher

    (interview here: https://projectavalon.net/forum4/show...emonkradio.com )

    This is what "I was waiting for" so maybe I just gave up a bit too soon...

    wouldn't be a bad idea to buy some silver just for the short "bump" to 50, or buy and hold for the longer run, either way your money is pretty safe in silver (as long as the economy doesn't completely implode)
    Hard times create strong men, Strong men create good times, Good times create weak men, Weak men create hard times.
    Where are you?

  33. The Following User Says Thank You to TargeT For This Post:

    thunder24 (24th December 2012)

  34. Link to Post #39
    Avalon Member SKAWF's Avatar
    Join Date
    7th January 2011
    Location
    london
    Posts
    732
    Thanks
    2,928
    Thanked 3,384 times in 633 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by Seikou-Kishi (here)
    In isolation, everything is worthless. Worth is in the general and literal sense a value judgement, and as such requires both a valued thing and valuer (which may be the same). Things valued for pecuniary or utilitarian purposes also have the purpose, all being strictly means to ends as opposed to those things the value of which is held to be inherent (people, for example). In this respect, gold isn't and probably never will have any value at all as food but for the various properties you note. Value therefore changes according to the needs of the moment. Though we would all hold food, water and air to be intrinsically more precious and vital to human life, if our concern is, for example, creating more electrically-conducive wiring, we would find a waldorf salad pretty unappealing.

    Is gold precious? I would say so, providing those two requirements are met: that it has a "needer" and a purpose for which it is needed. We can consider the preciousness of a thing in relation to those things which would fulfil the same function. If it scores better for electrical conductivity than copper (it does), then for purposes of electrical conductivity, gold will always have a baseline value higher than copper.

    It sounds like a good argument to say that if there is a lot of something in circulation, it's value must be lowered by that fact, but the high circulation of anything cannot be held to be a prerequisite of preciousness; oxygen is all over the place.
    i had to look a bit deeper into this.

    first i thought of my ferrets...

    maybe not of great monetary value, but to me they are precious.
    (they are one offs. you cant get my ferrets anywhere else.)
    then it occured to me that 'precious' can also be applied to a human

    as in 'be careful with that... he's very precious about it'

    at this point i had to look up the definition.

    1. Of high cost or worth; valuable.
    2. Highly esteemed; cherished.
    3. Dear; beloved.
    4. Affectedly dainty or overrefined: precious mannerisms.
    5. Informal Thoroughgoing; unmitigated: a precious mess.

    based on this, even though i stand by my reasoning...

    i will happily now accept that gold is a precious metal.
    when i went there nothing happened!, i was bored out of my mind..................in the Twilight Zone.

  35. The Following User Says Thank You to SKAWF For This Post:

    TargeT (24th December 2012)

  36. Link to Post #40
    Avalon Member Seikou-Kishi's Avatar
    Join Date
    23rd November 2010
    Location
    Middanġeard
    Posts
    2,194
    Thanks
    2,819
    Thanked 5,331 times in 1,296 posts

    Default Re: Is gold precious?

    Quote Posted by SKAWF (here)
    Quote Posted by Seikou-Kishi (here)
    In isolation, everything is worthless. Worth is in the general and literal sense a value judgement, and as such requires both a valued thing and valuer (which may be the same). Things valued for pecuniary or utilitarian purposes also have the purpose, all being strictly means to ends as opposed to those things the value of which is held to be inherent (people, for example). In this respect, gold isn't and probably never will have any value at all as food but for the various properties you note. Value therefore changes according to the needs of the moment. Though we would all hold food, water and air to be intrinsically more precious and vital to human life, if our concern is, for example, creating more electrically-conducive wiring, we would find a waldorf salad pretty unappealing.

    Is gold precious? I would say so, providing those two requirements are met: that it has a "needer" and a purpose for which it is needed. We can consider the preciousness of a thing in relation to those things which would fulfil the same function. If it scores better for electrical conductivity than copper (it does), then for purposes of electrical conductivity, gold will always have a baseline value higher than copper.

    It sounds like a good argument to say that if there is a lot of something in circulation, it's value must be lowered by that fact, but the high circulation of anything cannot be held to be a prerequisite of preciousness; oxygen is all over the place.
    i had to look a bit deeper into this.

    first i thought of my ferrets...

    maybe not of great monetary value, but to me they are precious.
    (they are one offs. you cant get my ferrets anywhere else.)
    then it occured to me that 'precious' can also be applied to a human

    as in 'be careful with that... he's very precious about it'

    at this point i had to look up the definition.

    1. Of high cost or worth; valuable.
    2. Highly esteemed; cherished.
    3. Dear; beloved.
    4. Affectedly dainty or overrefined: precious mannerisms.
    5. Informal Thoroughgoing; unmitigated: a precious mess.

    based on this, even though i stand by my reasoning...

    i will happily now accept that gold is a precious metal.
    Yeah if I might be so bold, I think the use of the term precious here is not actually the same kind of thing, where it means more delicate, fussy, etc., rather than of high value. A person could be precious in the sense in which a mother might say "look after my ____, they're very precious to me"

    It's the inherent-vs-utilitarian distinction of preciousness: inherent preciousness has two requirements (the well-reguarded thing and the one who regards them well) where utilitarian preciousness has three (the precious thing, the purpose to which it is put, and the person who appreciates this useage).

    Your ferrets have "inherent preciousness", that is, they're precious to you because of what they are. That's why there's no replacement for them; even if another ferret could do everything yours do, the purpose of the ferret is not the source of the value.

    That's just the thing about preciousness though. Whether it's inherent preciousness/preciousness per se or utilitarian preciousness, preciousness is a value judgement and as such not a fact, but an opinion. Opinions are never true or false (they can be well- or badly-founded opinions), but since they don't make a factual claim, they're not true or false.

    Take your ferrets. They're very precious to you, but to me they're no more or less precious than the next ferret. It's not that either of us is wrong, it's just that our different perspectives give us different estimations of their preciousness. In this sense, to say gold is or is not precious implies a logical fallacy; rather, preciousness is all about "being held to be", "seeming", and so on. In other words, it would be true to say "gold is precious sometimes, to some people, in certain situations and for various reasons", but never to say simply "gold is precious" or "gold is not precious"; these are shorthands for longer, implied ideas ("Gold is precious to me", "gold is precious for jewellery-lovers", "gold is not precious to the hungry man" and so on).
    Last edited by Seikou-Kishi; 24th December 2012 at 05:37.

  37. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Seikou-Kishi For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (24th December 2012), SKAWF (24th December 2012)

+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts