Is Dr. Malone Controlled Opposition?

[T Smith]

Karen Kingston's pleading and heart-wrenching video, posted earlier this month, has garnered very little traction in the alternative-news community. As if damage control has successfully stamped out what could have been a devastating fire.

Dr. Malone is apparently a very important figurehead among the anti-vaxx/anti-mRNA/anti-transhumanism community. Questioning his integrity and intentions has certainly ushered a deafening sound of crickets among the usual pontiffs.

A0HiIzKV8Pqo/

And now, on the heals of Kingston's impassioned scream from the rooftop, an ABC news affiliate is quietly reporting she has gone missing. (https://abc7chicago.com/nekendra-karen-kingston-playa-del-carmen-barcelo-hotel-missing-woman/13677580/) But despite the fact she is well-known among the anti-vaxx movement, no one is covering this (either confirming or discrediting) nor making any connections between her frightened-laden video and her subsequent disappearance. Even Mike Adams, who interviewed Karen (https://banned.video/watch?id=646ccf1961bacaf6a62798af) as a whistleblower and who considers her an important voice exposing the criminal rollout, is seemingly brushing the story and Kingston's recent remarks under the rug while subtly apologizing for Dr. Malone. (https://www.naturalnews.com/2023-08-17-karen-kingston-may-be-suffering-adverse-effects-of-malaria-treatment-says-family-member.html)

To my mind, however, none of her charges have been addressed. I'm not suggesting those charges are correct, but I do respect her judgement and I do know she is laying out the truth as she sees it. That said, when digging for truth, no one is above reproach.

Which begs the question, is Dr. Malone controlled opposition?

[mojo]

There is something odd about him as he filed a law suit on Dr Jane Ruby who is another well known person speaking out on the dangers of mRNA. Also didnt Dr Malone invent the tech? I don't like to accuse a person until we have more facts but something is very strange.

[Sue (Ayt)]

Dr. Lee Merritt mentioned this somewhere in her recent interview below. It was an interesting, speculative interview that included a wide variety of topics.

Courtenay and her touched on Karen Kingston and wondered what what going on with her. Dr. Merritt mentioned that they were friends, but she was quite concerned about "something" going on with her, specifically mentioning her last substack posts which were odd, she said, where she posted the names and locations of her family, and used capital L's throughout. (I haven't read this substack).
They also discussed disinfo agents, inserted to muddy the waters, but didn't specifically implicate Dr. Malone, or not. Sorry - I don't remember exactly when the topic was discussed in this 2 hour interview. But the entire interview is fascinating.

Ep. 295: Vaccine Bioweapons & Electromagnetic Activation w/ Dr. Lee Merritt
2 hour 4 minutes Posted Aug 21, 2023 at 12:28 pm.

In this episode, Courtenay welcomes everyone's favorite “medical rebel” Dr. Lee Merritt back to the show. This conversation ties together speculative evidence supporting that the Covid-19 vaccine was designed to be a bioweapon. Through a thread of overhead lies like how disease is transmitted, what causes symptoms, and of course the origins of Covid-19 itself, there are many questions your hosts aren’t afraid to ask including what’s really happening with the surge in electromagnetic frequencies (i.e. 5G) and vaccine side effects?
https://podbay.fm/p/the-courtenay-turner-podcast/e/1692638913

[T Smith]

There is something odd about him as he filed a law suit on Dr Jane Ruby who is another well known person speaking out on the dangers of mRNA. Also didnt Dr Malone invent the tech? I don't like to accuse a person until we have more facts but something is very strange.

Agreed. I'm not accusing Dr. Malone at all. I just want to see him respond to the lipids vs. nano-partial technology claim (Karen asserts they aren't lipids, but nano-tech) and defend his interpretation of contracts and the law, which (he claims) renders Pfizer untouchable. But when those being pressed merely respond with "shut up" and "stop asking questions" instead of with measured or plausible arguments, I for one sit up and take notice.

[Gwin Ru]

...

... from Karen Kingston's substack:

Apologies and Reconciliation (https://karenkingston.substack.com/p/apologies-and-reconciliation)

My heartfelt apologies to friends, family, colleagues, and supporters that I have caused worry and distress due to my silence and absence

https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_80,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fbucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffb7487a3-a300-4dac-b786-2f59f66145eb_2048x1365.jpeg (https://substack.com/profile/75298014-karen-kingston) Karen Kingston (https://substack.com/@karenkingston)

Aug 21, 2023

August 20, 2023: My sincere and deeply heartfelt apologies to those who I’ve caused worry and distress due to my long-term silence and absence. Without going into details, the expression “truth is stranger than fiction” accurately describes the last 30 days of my life. I can state with the utmost confidence that I am currently safe from harm because of the power of your prayers and God’s good grace.


see video embedded in Karen's post (https://karenkingston.substack.com/p/apologies-and-reconciliation)
Did I Make a Cautious Decision Using Good Judgement?
To put some context around my extended period of silence and absence from all media, after returning from Florida on July 25, 2023, I called and spoke with Ernest Luque. Ernest is a Director from Alpha Special Services (a security firm that offers armed security guards). After our initial conversation that morning, I had a second call with Ernest in the afternoon, during which he informed me that he was a former Pentagon employee and FBI agent; and that he had access to many government files. Ernest informed me that according to some of these government files, some of the research I had been speaking about and “my messaging” had gotten myself onto an alleged government ‘hit list’ and that my life was in grave danger. To be honest, I was under a great deal of stress and operating on a very limited amount of sleep when Ernest and I were having this conversation. For all I know, Ernest is one of the greatest salesmen ever and perhaps he was ‘embellishing some details’ to heighten my sense of fear or urgency, because I hired him on the spot as my armed security service company before ending that second call.

So Then What Happened?
Well over the next 36 hours (after hiring Alpha Security Services) I made the decision to leave the United States upon my own volition. Now you may ask, “Why would you leave the United States after hiring an armed security firm?” Great question!

The reason I decided to leave the United States was due a series of events and personal conversations (completely independent of Ernest’s Alpha Security firm or services) that led me to believe that it was in the best interest for my personal safety to not to be able to be tracked or trace within the United States (or North America) through my cell phone, my computers, or the community street cameras that are ubiquitous throughout southern California. The decision to leave the US was a decision I made 100% on my own.

So Where Am I Now?
While I’m not currently in the United States, at this very moment I am staying at a very nice Ramada Hotel with exceptional security. I will be returning home to the states soon.

Thank You
From my heart and soul, I want to thank all of you who have prayed for me and my family. Your prayers have comforted me and covered me and my family with protection. Your continued support has literally been lifesaving.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


Now... Malone... well, he KNOWS what the whole thing is all about with his DARPA connection/funding.

The whole thing:


Targeted Individuals: experiences, problems and solutions (https://projectavalon.net/forum4/showthread.php?99857-Targeted-Individuals-experiences-problems-and-solutions&p=1572759&viewfull=1#post1572759)



De-platformed Humans... The Internet of Soulless Bodies... (https://projectavalon.net/forum4/showthread.php?121710-De-platformed-Humans...-The-Internet-of-Soulless-Bodies...)

So... about everything regarding COVID 19 and the vaccines are smoke & mirrors to deflect from the above links content and which is what Dr. Lee Merritt is after: how is it transmitted? and her focus on electromagnetism and other "Fields"... "Through a Glass Darkly (http://whale.to/b/baker.html)".

[TravelerJim]

I appreciate you making a thread on this, I am not sure what to make of Malone. I am a big fan of George Webb and he questions the legtimacy of Malone all the time.

On Kingston, I like her work and her background. One thing I do consider about her is the use of mind/body weapons against her. I am sure the technology is there.

[jaybee]

.

Karen Kingston has returned to the US and given an interview to Mike Adams on Brighteon -

She has obviously been through a horrible time where she became very sleep deprived, afraid and in fear for her life... and that of her family -

she disconnected from her family and friends and is now very apologetic about her actions and the concern she caused by going to Mexico then disappearing (ie going into hiding -)

Karen must have been subjected to a psyop designed to shut her up and at the same time (IMO) create distrust towards Robert Malone... she looks better than she did but still seems unwell but is now trying to explain how scared she was and she thinks she may have been poisoned as well ...


around 3:20 she says about how her security in the past has de-escalated her fears but this time they really escalated the fear...saying there were lots of CIA/Pentagon files on her and a 'hit' had been ordered - and @ 4:00 - that people who she had conversations with who normally de-escalted her fears - they were elevating them... this IMO are probably a couple of people delivering alternative news but are really plants who together with her Security were working to scare the hell out of her and break her - and cast aspersions on Robert Malone -

she doesn't name names, but it's obvious if you are following the story that she is referring to Malone...when she says in the bit starting around 11:33.... how sleep deprived and fearful she was and in fight or flight mode and could see how people could take away that she was insinuating that certain people had ill intentions for her but that's not what she meant...

Karen - "I was trying in my sleep deprived, heightened fear state - trying to figure out a way to identify someone who could help - and ask for help and I did a very poor job of that so I apologise for that...."

IMO Karen was worked on + scared half to death by certain people around her and her 'security' + probably encouraged to make a public appeal to Robert Malone to call off the 'hit'.... knowing that that could be used to split opinions about Malone and create distrust - - - in another thread where this all came up - I said that I believed Dr Robert Malone was on our side - and nothing has happened since to change my mind...

Robert Malone's not stupid and must understand what has happened and the way Karen has been manipulated but felt he had to put a stop to it and has instigated court proceedings against a couple of people (think it's a couple) - Jane Ruby being one of them - - - -

anyway here's the interview for anyone who's interested... you have to feel for Karen who has been to hell and back with it all - and is trying to recover and reconnect with her family and community...


Karen Kingston speaks out in exclusive first interview after nerve-wracking close calls in Mexico(56:49)


cc0cc983-bf79-4342-a8e8-6f6effdb49a8

[norman]

It's been good to hear from her at last.

At the time she made that phone video I thought she was wrong to imply what she did because even the worst case scenario was a corporate hit, in my mind.

But, this doesn't, at all, take the heat off Malone in the general truth seeker scrutiny sense. His story doesn't add up. I know it, many others know it and Karen knows it. Controlled opposition ? . . . . hard to be sure yet, but a slippery piece of work who is far more involved in the great vaxx program than he wants to let on, and who admits, himself, is in the 'first responder' category in the orbit of the CIA and it's interests.

From the moment Malone popped up, the truth seeker world has been fixated on 'mRNA in the shots'. Turns out not only did he NOT invent it, the whole mRNA thing is probably a deflection away from what's really going on with the shots.

[jaybee]

It's been good to hear from her at last.

At the time she made that phone video I thought she was wrong to imply what she did because even the worst case scenario was a corporate hit, in my mind.

But, this doesn't, at all, take the heat off Malone in the general truth seeker scrutiny sense. His story doesn't add up. I know it, many others know it and Karen knows it. Controlled opposition ? . . . . hard to be sure yet, but a slippery piece of work who is far more involved in the great vaxx program than he wants to let on, and who admits, himself, is in the 'first responder' category in the orbit of the CIA and it's interests.

From the moment Malone popped up, the truth seeker world has been fixated on 'mRNA in the shots'. Turns out not only did he NOT invent it, the whole mRNA thing is probably a deflection away from what's really going on with the shots.


One thing we can be 100% sure of ---- there are going to be individuals planted in the Alternative Media and they have a job to do - and that job is to basically divide and rule - inserting distracting info and at times being called upon to help destroy the credibility of genuine whistleblowers -

Just have to decide who they might be :) - who is on our side and who isn't -

Sometimes opinions on this will differ.... no problem :thumbsup:

[gini]

It's been good to hear from her at last.

At the time she made that phone video I thought she was wrong to imply what she did because even the worst case scenario was a corporate hit, in my mind.

But, this doesn't, at all, take the heat off Malone in the general truth seeker scrutiny sense. His story doesn't add up. I know it, many others know it and Karen knows it. Controlled opposition ? . . . . hard to be sure yet, but a slippery piece of work who is far more involved in the great vaxx program than he wants to let on, and who admits, himself, is in the 'first responder' category in the orbit of the CIA and it's interests.

From the moment Malone popped up, the truth seeker world has been fixated on 'mRNA in the shots'. Turns out not only did he NOT invent it, the whole mRNA thing is probably a deflection away from what's really going on with the shots.

You mean the nano sh#t & the graphene in the clotshots? Or the difference between modrna /mrna? ,And, did(and would he really be able?) mr Malone really distract us from the bigger picture of genocide & the mass psy op called Covid?
Or is perhaps discussing and doubting him the desired distraction?

[norman]

You mean the nano sh#t & the graphene in the clotshots? Or the difference between modrna /mdrna? ,And, did(and would he really be able?) mr Malone really distract us from the bigger picture of genocide & the mass psy op called Covid?
Or is perhaps discussing and doubting him the desired distraction?



George Webb asks a few very good questions about Malone. No answers are forthcoming yet.

Even before I was aware of George Webb's investigations I had a bunch of intuitive red flags about Malone and the covid narrative.

At this point I have Malone, McCullough and Rand Paul in my possible 'misdirectors' box. Between the three of them, they've got the covid/vax narrative pinned down somewhere miles behind the ball.

In a way, Rand Paul has been my biggest disappointment. I used to see him as an all round good guy in these troubled times, but the lock he's got on the covid narrative in the official government hunt for the truth is headbangingly awful to watch.


Re: modRNA, I still can't work out and understand if it's any less dependant on very cold storage and handling than mRNA would be.

[jaybee]

George Webb asks a few very good questions about Malone. No answers are forthcoming yet.


Do you have a video of him asking those questions - I haven't come across George Webb much - only in passing from what I can remember....I'd like to run him and his questions through the Intuitive Fake Detector... :)

Failing that what are the questions...?

cheers

[norman]

George Webb asks a few very good questions about Malone. No answers are forthcoming yet.


Do you have a video of him asking those questions - I haven't come across George Webb much - only in passing from what I can remember....I'd like to run him and his questions through the Intuitive Fake Detector... :)

Failing that what are the questions...?

cheers

This is audio only, and I edited it down from over 2 hours of 2 parts of an interview by Courtenay Turner. It covers the issues without the off topic natter there was quite a lot of.
https://app.box.com/s/wega5jjrlpns9xwgmjlg6t5lc1i8qqsh

[jaybee]

George Webb asks a few very good questions about Malone. No answers are forthcoming yet.


Do you have a video of him asking those questions - I haven't come across George Webb much - only in passing from what I can remember....I'd like to run him and his questions through the Intuitive Fake Detector... :)

Failing that what are the questions...?

cheers

This is audio only, and I edited it down from over 2 hours of 2 parts of an interview by Courtenay Turner. It covers the issues without the off topic natter there was quite a lot of.
https://app.box.com/s/wega5jjrlpns9xwgmjlg6t5lc1i8qqsh


ok thanks... that's over an hour long so I will go through it later....

and go and find a video of him -

[T Smith]

I thought she was wrong to imply what she did because even the worst case scenario was a corporate hit, in my mind.

Agree, but... the way I understand it Big Pharma corporate world/intelligence agencies are two sides of the same coin. It was clear to me in her video she was acting irrational, had no idea what was going on, and was very scared. And probably had every reason to be.


But, this doesn't, at all, take the heat off Malone in the general truth seeker scrutiny sense. His story doesn't add up.

Notice that neither of them went there. I doubt Karen will ever talk about Dr. Malone again.

[jaybee]

George Webb asks a few very good questions about Malone. No answers are forthcoming yet.


Do you have a video of him asking those questions - I haven't come across George Webb much - only in passing from what I can remember....I'd like to run him and his questions through the Intuitive Fake Detector... :)

Failing that what are the questions...?

cheers

This is audio only, and I edited it down from over 2 hours of 2 parts of an interview by Courtenay Turner. It covers the issues without the off topic natter there was quite a lot of.
https://app.box.com/s/wega5jjrlpns9xwgmjlg6t5lc1i8qqsh


ok thanks... that's over an hour long so I will go through it later....

and go and find a video of him -


ok..... that was quite a hit piece ... but the accusations were vague and rushed through - IMO -

so I looked further afield and George Webb - aka George Webb Sweigert - didn't pass the 'test' I'm afraid -

I don't want to spend any more time on it but I've seen enough - anyone wanting to check him out - search the name George Webb Sweigert....

my trust in Dr Robert Malone still stands....

cheers

[norman]

. . . that was quite a hit piece ...



Is this, too ?

https://rumble.com/v2nh8xc-premiere-watch-the-water-2-closing-chapter.html

v2kvtho/?pub=1yatds

[jaybee]

Is this, too ?

{post snipped see video above #17}



I will take a look later or tomorrow - but I have remarked in another post on the subject of Malone - that I think Stew Peters is genuine but has possibly been manipulated to distrust Malone - and I have 'suspicions' about Bryan Ardis - I'll let you know if those two opinions remain after watching the video...

:thumbsup:

[jaybee]

Is this, too ?

{post snipped see video above #17}



I will take a look later or tomorrow - but I have remarked in another post on the subject of Malone - that I think Stew Peters is genuine but has possibly been manipulated to distrust Malone - and I have 'suspicions' about Bryan Ardis - I'll let you know if those two opinions remain after watching the video...

:thumbsup:


I watched around half of it - that was all I could take of Bryan Ardis who I find very irritating - something about him, the way he delivers like he's the cleverest person in the world who has all the answers but no one will listen to him.... he doesn't pass the test for me....

nothing has changed regarding my opinions - sorry

[Vangelo]

Until now, I have ignored the talk of Malone being controlled opposition because in 5th generation warfare, one of the techniques is to introduce doubt and division amongst the group. I also did not bother to watch/pursue the water/venom stuff because it seems farfetched to me. But the last few posts motivated me to finally watch. I am glad I did. Seems to me there is something here that we need to investigate.
Source: https://www.rumble.com/video/v2kvtho/?pub=1yatds

UPDATE: let me state that watching this video has no convinced me that Malone or the other doctors are controlled opposition. Instead, the video has convinced me that there is more to this than I realized and we need experts to investigate these claims.

[Delight]

Until now, I have ignored the talk of Malone being controlled opposition because in 5th generation warfare, one of the techniques is to introduce doubt and division amongst the group. I also did not bother to watch/pursue the water/venom stuff because it seems farfetched to me. But the last few posts motivated me to finally watch. I am glad I did. Seems to me there is something here that we need to investigate.
Source: https://www.rumble.com/video/v2kvtho/?pub=1yatds

Allopathic medicine itself is "controlled poisoning" to cause an effect. My personal take is that I once upon a time believed in allopathic medicine. I have compassion for all who still believe. People do change their minds and MAYBE all that we perceive is a landscape created to place us each IN disillusion?

From everything I see, we are in a spiritual war. The tactics of the Devil (always is Lived backwards) are based on this realm's obfuscations of our responsibility for what is created OF OUR EXPERIENCE.

We know there is mind control and manipulation and that we are given scripts to play out such as in books and movies. People are surprised by how predictive programming is possible. It is due to how this realm reflects what we believe and act on.

That is why I think my job is to forgive everything in my purview and clear my subconscious of believed fiction. I do not know Robert Malone. Therefore, he is not anything but a representative of ideas to me. I am a committed antivaxx advocate so I stand there. No jabs and no allopathic poisons and no POISONS allowed into the environment of which body is part.

Beyond and below all else, IMO IF I believe in anyone being my opposition, if I treat That Person as my enemy, they will conform. DO UNTO OTHERS as you would have them do is profound. This is to me the paradox that we create what others reflect by what we do FIRST. Today my best guess at what is happening for me is that HERE I live in a paradox. Maybe the ultimate is when I forgive the whole world I created.

v2kvtho/?pub=mpxgj

[norman]

Until now, I have ignored the talk of Malone being controlled opposition because in 5th generation warfare, one of the techniques is to introduce doubt and division amongst the group. I also did not bother to watch/pursue the water/venom stuff because it seems farfetched to me. But the last few posts motivated me to finally watch. I am glad I did. Seems to me there is something here that we need to investigate.
Source: https://www.rumble.com/video/v2kvtho/?pub=1yatds

UPDATE: let me state that watching this video has no convinced me that Malone or the other doctors are controlled opposition. Instead, the video has convinced me that there is more to this than I realized and we need experts to investigate these claims.

That's exactly the thrust of my point too.

For some reason, the entire vax/covid public investigation has ground to a halt, and worse, there are people getting uppity about getting it moving again.

The debate ( if you can call it that ) today is exactly the same as it was 18 months or so ago. We've got all the answers and there's no need to dig any further, right ?

Why IS that ?

You've seen as well as I have, that there's a lot more digging and dot joining to do.

[mountain_jim]

Malone fires back.

https://www.zerohedge.com/medical/delights-pfizermoderna-catfight

< more embedded links at link >

The Delights Of The Pfizer/Moderna Catfight

BY TYLER DURDEN
TUESDAY, SEP 05, 2023 - 05:00 AM
Authored by Robert Malone via The Brownstone Institute (https://brownstone.org/articles/delights-of-the-pfizer-moderna-catfight/),

I am a bit embarrassed to admit that I am taking a perverse pleasure in watching this catfight between Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna play out.

Not to gloat, but I find it validating and rather satisfying to watch these companies file lawsuits and counter lawsuits that boil down to a schoolyard squabble over who came up with the ideas and initial proof of concept for using mRNA for developing drugs and vaccines – when neither actually did the initial “proof of concept” work.

Companies that have exploited and unethically weaponized my early work and ideas for enormous profit while also seeking to write me out of history.

“O what a tangled web.”

https://assets.zerohedge.com/s3fs-public/styles/inline_image_mobile/public/inline-images/2023-09-04_13-14-09.jpg?itok=ZvZ1qUJY

Just to be clear (for the haters), I received a total of one US dollar for my pioneering work, discoveries, and patents relating to my graduate research involving mRNA delivery at the Salk Institute, UCSD and Vical between 1986 and 1990. I played no role in development of any gene therapy-based COVID vaccine; the record shows that I was one of the early objectors to the rushed worldwide deployment of this technology, and I actively highlighted the (now proven) fact that the SARS-CoV-2 “Spike” protein expressed using this technology is a toxin. For speaking about which I was widely criticized, “fact-checked” and ridiculed in corporate media (and by the likes of Dr. Paul Offit).

Furthermore, I discovered and documented the profound toxicity (in both cell culture and in animals) associated with the use of cationic lipids for delivering mRNA and DNA during the 1990s, documented and disclosed this at a conference (that I organized) where I invited and first met Dr. K. Kariko (about a decade after my initial work at the Salk).

Around this time, Jill and I abandoned the nano-lipid technology and turned to discovering and developing other methods for delivering nucleic acids into cells and tissues for vaccine development and other indications. Including the initial proof of concept and patent covering the use of gene therapy technologies for eliciting a mucosal immune response. Those are all documented and readily verified facts. (https://www.rwmalonemd.com/general-4)

https://assets.zerohedge.com/s3fs-public/styles/inline_image_mobile/public/inline-images/2023-09-04_13-15-37.jpg?itok=KGRnTiG5
Images from the 1990 filed patents (priority date 1989)

Throughout my career, I have had to deal with other academics who have asserted that THEY were the ones that first discovered and developed what I had clearly pioneered so long ago. Dr. David Weiner (U Penn), Dr. Harriet Robinson (Merck, then Emory), Dr. Margret Liu (Merck), the list goes on and on. They all profited greatly from this. Success has many fathers, failure is a bastard.

This was partly the consequence of the “reduction to practice” of the work for vaccine purposes having occurred at a small La Jolla biotech startup called “Vical,” and my having signed non-disclosure and employment agreements which constrained my ability to disclose what I had done there or to influence the subsequent tide of events in any way.

Suffice to say, academic self-promotion, avarice, hubris, and greed are often well rewarded, and when pharmaceutical industry interests merge with academic competitiveness, then ethics gets to ride in the back of the bus. Meanwhile, while I was a young “soft money” academic, the CEO of Vical (Dr. Vijay Samant, formerly of Merck) sent me a cease and desist letter threatening to sue me if I disclosed or used the discoveries which I had made while working for that firm.

Then along come Drs. Katie Kariko (U Penn and later VP BioNTech- formerly a Hungarian spy) and Drew Weissman (U Penn- trained by Dr. Anthony Fauci)- about a decade later after my work and initial reduction to practice – who wrote a review paper in a high profile academic journal discussing my ideas without citing my work. They then tour widely promoting the logic and technology. This review then becomes the basis of a series of Wiki pages, promoting this pair and others as the original inventors.

Meanwhile, the Vical patents issue, the initial 1990 filing dates (with a priority date of 1989) become public, and it becomes harder for those who have sought to claim credit for my work to continue to do so. But, as is often observed, a lie can circle the world while the truth is still getting its shoes tied. And in academia, it is all about pedigrees and publicity. The stories of academic “stolen valor” are legion.

Wired magazine (a publication with close CIA connections) hyped the tech, asserting that Vical would be the next Microsoft. Vical (and Merck) literally spent billions of dollars trying to develop vaccine products (using plasmid DNA rather than mRNA), and completely failed. Which does not stop them from suing Curevac for infringement with that companies early mRNA delivery and product development research.

Then the initial patents expired. Vical market capitalization collapsed to well below cash on hand, and the company merged with a smaller startup. Dr. Vijay Samant retired in comfort after over a decade collecting a huge salary. Stockholder lawsuits went nowhere. DARPA launched a funding initiative and capitalized Moderna. The German government did likewise with BioNTech.

Fast forward to 2020


Early in the COVIDcrisis, Operation Warp Speed and the NIAID Vaccine Research Center had focused on the unproven use of cationic lipid formulations of mRNA encoding the spike protein as the way to save the world from an engineered coronavirus produced at the Wuhan Institute of Virology with assistance and funding from a wide range of US Government entities (CIA, NIH, USAID, DoD, State Department). They initially did this in close cooperation with a Boston-based American company (Moderna) that was largely the creation of the CIAs technology development arm called DARPA (Defense Advanced Research Project Agency).

U Penn licensed a Kariko and Weissman patent involving the incorporation of Pseudouridine into the mRNA (with no claims issued concerning use for vaccines) to a holding company, which then licensed to both Moderna and BioNTech. A third firm seeking to develop mRNA vaccines (Curevac) – funded in part by Elon Musk- did not license the U Penn patent and developed a SARS-CoV-2 mRNA vaccine that used a lower dose of mRNA/lipid and did not have the Pseudouridine (pseudo-mRNA) issues. Unlike Moderna and BioNTech, Curevac was more methodical, traditional (and ethical) in its product development, but its initial antibody titers and seroconversion (at a reduced dose) were lower than those reported by Moderna and BioNTech, and so it was relegated to the ash-heap of history.

A wall of marketing hype was built around Katie Kariko and Drew Weissman as the original inventors of use of mRNA for vaccination purposes, with initial articles by Boston-based “STAT News,” followed by CNN and the New York Times. A huge corporate media buzz was developed promoting that Kariko and Weissman should be awarded a Nobel Prize (Medicine or Chemistry) for their “pioneering” work. And Moderna, with close involvement of MIT liposome technology and drug discovery superstar Professor Dr. Robert Langer, asserted that it had the dominant patent position for using mRNA as a drug or for vaccine purposes.

Jill and I objected to my being written out of history (including on Wikipedia); Jill wrote up an account of the actual history of the inventions, complete with citations to and copies of the original invention disclosures, patents, data etc. including the original patent filed by the Salk Institute and then inexplicably dropped without notifying me. The summary was sent to many – Salk Institute, UCSD, a close colleague and former collaborator at the Karolinska (now a full professor who sat on the Nobel Prize selection committee), Dr. Robert Langer (who initially claimed ignorance of my role but then conceded the facts), and many others. Letters were sent to STAT News (who refused to retract or alter their publications promoting the Kariko and Weissman stolen valor claims), CNN (who did seem to edit, back off of and retract some of what they had been pushing), and the New York Times (which definitely edited their prior video and written essays to remove claims about Kariko and Weissman being the original source of these ideas).

Kariko and Weissman received millions from the Lasker Award (often considered the American Nobel) and similar awards from the governments of Israel and Spain. But to the astonishment and disappointment of Nature magazine and US Corporate media, no Nobel prize in medicine or chemistry was forthcoming. The Nobel committee had long since reviewed the actual scientific contributions of Kariko and Weissman to the field, and determined that they were not sufficient to merit this distinction. And at that time, many (including myself) had spoken out about the risks of what had been developed for “vaccination” against COVID-19, and the bloom was off the rose.

At this point, it became clear that my role as the inventor of this technology was what gave my concerns about the safety of the mRNA COVID-19 shots gravitas. This then became the reason for mainstream media to deny my role as inventor.

Moderna and Pfizer were awarded “vaccine” contracts from governments across the world, and consequently reported record profits. Their market capitalization went through the roof. Moderna leadership (including Robert Langer) began “divesting” of Moderna stock. And then the patent fights began. The latest version of the various companies spun out of the University of British Columbia research group which had developed the updated version of the cationic lipid formulations which I had worked with filed patent infringement lawsuits against Moderna.

And Moderna filed lawsuits against BioNTech and their Pfizer partner/licensee claiming infringement on issued Moderna patents which, despite the eight previously issued (and expired) Vical patents which cover mRNA and DNA vaccines, claim inventorship of the idea and reduction to practice of mRNA vaccines.

At which point I decided to dig into the actual Kariko, Weissman and Moderna patents to see what are the actual issued claims. Please understand, at this point in time, the Vical patents have expired. I have no (financial) dog in this fight. Only a bystander’s perverse interest and a lingering desire to not be written out of history. And as discussed in a prior August 26, 2022 substack titled “Moderna sues BioNTech/Pfizer?” what I find when I actually do the research (in contrast to the corporate media “reporters”) is that – somehow – consistent with Dr. Robert Langer claiming no knowledge of my role in discovery and development of these ideas as a young graduate student, Moderna and its intellectual property team has completely failed to cite my prior work and the issued patents.

Which brings me to the present. Pfizer is now claiming that the Moderna patents, which Moderna sought to weaponize against Pfizer/BioNTech, are invalid because the technology and invention of using mRNA for vaccination purposes was first disclosed and reduced to practice in 1990.

In other words, Pfizer/BioNTech are now citing my work (and that of my close colleagues) to dispute the Moderna patent infringement claims – precisely as I had recommended in my August 2022 essay.

Please keep in mind that Thompson/Reuters has close ties (at the board of directors level) with Pfizer, my initial reporting on which conflict of interest was one of the key reasons I was deplatformed by Linked-In (the first time).

https://assets.zerohedge.com/s3fs-public/styles/inline_image_mobile/public/inline-images/2023-09-04_13-16-54.jpg?itok=kpdi_i2p

Aug 28 (Reuters) – Pfizer (PFE.N) and BioNTech (22UAy.DE) asked a US government tribunal on Monday to cancel patents on COVID-19 vaccine technology that rival Moderna (MRNA.O) has accused the companies of infringing.

Pfizer and its German partner told the US Patent Office’s Patent Trial and Appeal Board that the two Moderna patents are “unimaginably broad” and cover a “basic idea that was known long before” their invention date of 2015.

Representatives for Moderna did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the filings.

Pfizer said in a statement on Monday that it and BioNTech’s vaccine was “based on BioNTech’s proprietary mRNA technology and developed by both BioNTech and Pfizer,” and that they remain confident in their intellectual property.

Pfizer and BioNTech have separately challenged the two patents and a third related Moderna patent in court in an ongoing Massachusetts federal lawsuit that Moderna filed against them last year.

Moderna in the lawsuit accused Pfizer and BioNTech of violating its patent rights in messenger-RNA vaccine technology. The case is one of several that have been brought by biotech companies seeking patent royalties from Moderna, Pfizer and BioNTech’s blockbuster COVID-19 vaccines.

Pfizer earned $37.8 billion from sales of its COVID-19 vaccine Comirnaty last year, while Moderna made $18.4 billion from its vaccine Spikevax.

The Patent Trial and Appeal Board hears challenges to patent validity based on “prior art” that challengers say disclosed the inventions before they were patented. Defendants frequently turn to the board as an alternative path to fend off patent infringement claims.

Pfizer and BioNTech said in their board petitions that scientists discovered that mRNA could be used for vaccines as early as 1990. They argued that Moderna’s patents were invalid based on separate patent applications and other publications from as early as 2004.

And that would be my work and inventions, that of my colleagues at Vical, and the issued but expired patents which Katie Kariko, Drew Weissman, U Penn, Moderna, and corporate media have tried so hard to write out of history.

The cases are BioNTech SE v. ModernaTX Inc, Patent Trial and Appeal Board, Nos. IPR2023-01358 and IPR2023-01359.

The “fact-checkers,” intelligence community (particularly MI6 and their edits to my Wikipedia page), U Penn and their surrogates, corporate media (and Alex Berenson) have gone to great length to “overlook,” deny, defame, and ridicule me as a liar for asserting that I did the work, had the original ideas, and made these inventions.

But the actual facts are now starting to become undeniable. And corporate media faces a paradox. Continue to conveniently “overlook” those papers I have authored and the issued but expired patents which explicitly list me as co-inventor (as Reuters has done above). Or come to grips with their own shoddy journalism, research and bias.

Having become (justifiably) quite cynical about such matters over the years, I strongly suspect that we will exclusively see the “convenient overlook” strategy.

[norman]

Alexis Bugnolo explains how Malone proved himself a faker hijacking the covid narrative from the start.

By extension, the "Lab Leak" story is a fake story so the people pushing it, including the Whitehouse and Rand Paul are lying. This conversation between him and Dr Jane Ruby adopts assumption about why all the lying.

I'm reluctant to adopt the same assumption trail but I do agree with Bugnolo's initial logic that exposes Malone and the lie. Without formulating it into the way he states it, I'd figured that bit out 3 years ago, for myself ( and got heat from several people for saying so ).

Actually, it was that realisation that caused me to more attentively scrutinise (intuitively) Joe Rogan and his amazingly powerful platform, and by extension from that, the people who pop up there for a shot of high intensity public exposure at, probably, well chosen timings. It has for me even evolved into a quite broad suspicion about the integrity or lack of it in the so called alternative media space. With CNN viewership now down to 80k per week, it's not alternative at all, it's the main media space and it's rife with all the bad practices there ever was before it came into being. Nowadays, Rogan isn't alone, there's plenty of them now.

TRUMP, MALONE AND THE LAB LEAK LIE | Dr. Jane Ruby

https://rumble.com/v6sswmd-trump-malone-and-the-lab-leak-lie-dr.-jane-ruby.html

v6qm0dj/?pub=1yatds