+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: "Out of Bounds" | After Dark - Channel 4 TV broadcast (May 1989)

  1. Link to Post #1
    UK Moderator/Librarian/Administrator Tintin's Avatar
    Join Date
    3rd June 2017
    Location
    Project Avalon library
    Language
    English
    Age
    54
    Posts
    5,447
    Thanks
    64,677
    Thanked 46,630 times in 5,415 posts

    Default "Out of Bounds" | After Dark - Channel 4 TV broadcast (May 1989)

    After Dark - Out of Bounds - Tony Benn; Democracy vs Secrecy [1989] - duration: 2 hours 38 minutes.

    05:48 (Tony Benn)
    “…the crucial question is a constitutional question. What we are discussing is the relationship between the government and governed. And the present government have said that you owe a lifelong obligation of confidentiality to the Crown.

    Who is the Crown? Did the Queen tell Peter Wright to get rid of Wilson [Harold]? No.Did Wilson who was her first [prime] minister tell Peter Wright to get rid of him? No.

    The Crown is a concrete emplacement, a state within a state, surrounded by barbed-wire, which is always in power….”
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    If any of you have, as I still do, a similar fascination with intelligence related material then you would most probably find this discussion that took place in May 1989 possibly really quite rivetingly compulsive viewing/listening.

    It took place following the release of the then new Official Secrets Act, still in effect today (with revisions). The latest version can be viewed here on the UK government website and downloaded here.

    I fondly remember watching the After Dark programmes with friends of mine after we had retired from the pub, and, being transfixed with mostly every programme many of which now only a distant memory. (I don’t remember seeing this one at the time.)

    Can you imagine them making a programme like this now?

    Anybody seeking insight into the activities of the SIS and partners [CIA] would find many of the personal testimonies here of enormous interest, and very educational.

    SUMMARY

    Discussion of the unaccountability of the secret services, with former MI5 and MI6 officers.

    Live and open ended discussion programme. The official Secrets Act has received royal ascent and will become law shortly after the making of this programme. No one knows how this will work out. This programme might be the last time consequently that these participants are not bound to silence. The panel includes spies, a defence journalist, MI5 member, CIA founder, MPs and a MI6 member.

    Michael Randle and Pat Pottle, who had recently confessed in a book to assisting a prison escape by the spy George Blake, were dropped from this programme ('Out of Bounds', tx. 13/5/1989) after Channel Four was threatened with contempt of court proceedings.

    Participants:
    John Underwood, with;

    • James Rusbridger
    • Rt Hon Tony Benn MP
    • Anthony Cavendish
    • Miles Copeland
    • Eddie Chapman
    • Adela Gooch

    The first programme of the third series was titled Out of Bounds: "1988 was the year of the tri-centenary of the Bill of Rights, yet in May 1989, in the shadowy studio of Channel 4's After Dark programme, a group of former British and US intelligence agents discussed the merits and evils of new legislation on official secrets.

    When this legislation completes its processes through Parliament such a gathering is likely to become illegal.

    The Financial Times wrote:
    "Channel 4's After Dark triumphantly broke all the rules from the beginning.... The first of the new series on Saturday proved that the formula is still working extremely well. The subject was official secrecy, and during the course of the night remarks included: 'I was in Egypt at the time, plotting the assassination of Nasser' and 'Wilson and Heath were destroyed in part by the action of intelligence agents' and (spoken with incredulity) 'You mean we shouldn't have got rid of Allende?' The hostility between just two of the participants, which often brings most life to the programme, occurred this time between Tony Benn and ex-CIA man Miles Copeland, and it was the fundamental difference in political outlook between these two which informed the entire discussion. Anyone who regarded Benn as a dangerous 'loony leftie' but watched right through until 2.00 may have been astonished at his thoroughly conservative British attitudes."
    Tony Benn wrote in his diary, later published as The End of an Era:
    "Saturday 13 May - In the evening I went to take part in this live television programme After Dark with John Underwood in the chair. It was an open-ended discussion which started at about midnight and went on till the early hours. The other participants were the historian Lord Dacre, Eddie Chapman, who had been a double agent during the war, Anthony Cavendish, who is a former MI6 and MI5 officer, Miles Copeland (an ex-CIA man), James Rusbridger, who has worked with MI5 at one stage, and Adela Gooch, a defence journalist from the Daily Telegraph. Every one of them made admissions or came out with most helpful information. I was terribly pleased with it."


    The Listener magazine described the programme:
    "The new Official Secrets Act has just received the Queen's assent. This may be the last time for some years that any disclosures can be made on such matters.... After Dark exists for mysterious reasons, probably something to do with a necessary safety-valve in a climate of increasing pressure on the media.... Its strength is that it has rescued that endangered species, genuinely spontaneous conversation, and presented it absolutely without frills. It does not have to rely on a presenter or on the glamour of its guests, as other talk shows do. Its force is its unique lack of inhibition in dealing with very controversial issues without exhibitionism...an invaluable programme. "


    Richard Norton-Taylor reported on guests who did not appear because of concerns about contempt of court:
    ""Michael Randle and Pat Pottle, who admitted helping the spy, George Blake, escape from prison in 1966... have been dropped from the... programme... Mr Randle and Mr Pottle were arrested and released on police bail last week after admitting in a book that they had helped Blake escape.'

    Last edited by Tintin; 29th July 2019 at 11:47.
    “If a man does not keep pace with [fall into line with] his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer. Let him step to the music which he hears, however measured or far away.” - Thoreau

  2. The Following 12 Users Say Thank You to Tintin For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (2nd January 2019), Billy (2nd January 2019), Chip (3rd January 2019), Dennis Leahy (3rd January 2019), Franny (3rd January 2019), happyuk (2nd January 2019), Mike (2nd January 2019), Satori (2nd January 2019), sijohn (3rd January 2019), The Moss Trooper (2nd January 2019), toppy (2nd January 2019), yelik (3rd January 2019)

  3. Link to Post #2
    UK Avalon Founder Bill Ryan's Avatar
    Join Date
    7th February 2010
    Location
    Ecuador
    Posts
    34,274
    Thanks
    209,041
    Thanked 457,563 times in 32,794 posts

    Default Re: "Out of Bounds" | After Dark - Channel 4 TV broadcast (May 1989)

    Thank you!

    Of all those in British politics, only half a dozen have earned my respect, right across the so-called (and very faux) left-right spectrum: Tony Benn, Margaret Thatcher, Norman Tebbit, Robin Cook, Enoch Powell, and George Galloway. (Not for discussion here! )

    Tony Benn had my highest regard of them all. He had integrity like solid steel.

  4. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Bill Ryan For This Post:

    happyuk (2nd January 2019), Mike (2nd January 2019), Tintin (2nd January 2019), toppy (2nd January 2019), yelik (3rd January 2019), Yoda (2nd January 2019)

  5. Link to Post #3
    Avalon Member The Moss Trooper's Avatar
    Join Date
    21st May 2017
    Posts
    677
    Thanks
    959
    Thanked 4,838 times in 650 posts

    Default Re: "Out of Bounds" | After Dark - Channel 4 TV broadcast (May 1989)

    Just as an aside, Miles Copeland, founding member of the CIA, is the father of Stewart Copeland, drummer and song writer in The Police.

    Dave McGowan's research into the relationship between intel-agencies and some bands is a real eye opener, as is Neil Sanders.


  6. The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to The Moss Trooper For This Post:

    Franny (3rd January 2019), happyuk (2nd January 2019), Mike (3rd January 2019), Tintin (2nd January 2019), toppy (3rd January 2019)

  7. Link to Post #4
    Wales Avalon Member
    Join Date
    8th October 2012
    Location
    Wales, UK
    Language
    English
    Age
    55
    Posts
    978
    Thanks
    5,974
    Thanked 7,223 times in 940 posts

    Default Re: "Out of Bounds" | After Dark - Channel 4 TV broadcast (May 1989)

    Great program. I will give this another watch later when I get the chance.
    Many time I would come home and watch these after a late evening.

    My personal numero uno in terms of politicians (again I can probably count them on less than one hand) would be
    Denis Healey, considered by many to be the greatest Prime Minister we never had:

    It seems unbelievable now, but this Denis Healey speech demonstrates that there was a time when the UK had to go cap-in-hand to the IMF for a bail-out, such was the state of the UK in the mid-seventies:


  8. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to happyuk For This Post:

    Tintin (3rd January 2019), toppy (3rd January 2019)

  9. Link to Post #5
    UK Moderator/Librarian/Administrator Tintin's Avatar
    Join Date
    3rd June 2017
    Location
    Project Avalon library
    Language
    English
    Age
    54
    Posts
    5,447
    Thanks
    64,677
    Thanked 46,630 times in 5,415 posts

    Default Re: "Out of Bounds" | After Dark - Channel 4 TV broadcast (May 1989)

    Quote Posted by Tintin (here)
    After Dark - Out of Bounds - Tony Benn; Democracy vs Secrecy [1989] - duration: 2 hours 38 minutes.

    05:48 (Tony Benn)
    “…the crucial question is a constitutional question. What we are discussing is the relationship between the government and governed. And the present government have said that you owe a lifelong obligation of confidentiality to the Crown.

    Who is the Crown? Did the Queen tell Peter Wright to get rid of Wilson [Harold]? No.Did Wilson who was her first [prime] minister tell Peter Wright to get rid of him? No.

    The Crown is a concrete emplacement, a state within a state, surrounded by barbed-wire, which is always in power….”
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    If any of you have, as I still do, a similar fascination with intelligence related material then you would most probably find this discussion that took place in May 1989 possibly really quite rivetingly compulsive viewing/listening.

    It took place following the release of the then new Official Secrets Act, still in effect today (with revisions). The latest version can be viewed here on the UK government website and downloaded here.

    I fondly remember watching the After Dark programmes with friends of mine after we had retired from the pub, and, being transfixed with mostly every programme many of which now only a distant memory. (I don’t remember seeing this one at the time.)

    Can you imagine them making a programme like this now?

    Anybody seeking insight into the activities of the SIS and partners [CIA] would find many of the personal testimonies here of enormous interest, and very educational.

    SUMMARY

    Discussion of the unaccountability of the secret services, with former MI5 and MI6 officers.

    Live and open ended discussion programme. The official Secrets Act has received royal ascent and will become law shortly after the making of this programme. No one knows how this will work out. This programme might be the last time consequently that these participants are not bound to silence. The panel includes spies, a defence journalist, MI5 member, CIA founder, MPs and a MI6 member.

    Michael Randle and Pat Pottle, who had recently confessed in a book to assisting a prison escape by the spy George Blake, were dropped from this programme ('Out of Bounds', tx. 13/5/1989) after Channel Four was threatened with contempt of court proceedings.

    Participants:
    John Underwood, with;

    • James Rusbridger
    • Rt Hon Tony Benn MP
    • Anthony Cavendish
    • Miles Copeland
    • Eddie Chapman
    • Adela Gooch

    The first programme of the third series was titled Out of Bounds: "1988 was the year of the tri-centenary of the Bill of Rights, yet in May 1989, in the shadowy studio of Channel 4's After Dark programme, a group of former British and US intelligence agents discussed the merits and evils of new legislation on official secrets.

    When this legislation completes its processes through Parliament such a gathering is likely to become illegal.

    The Financial Times wrote:
    "Channel 4's After Dark triumphantly broke all the rules from the beginning.... The first of the new series on Saturday proved that the formula is still working extremely well. The subject was official secrecy, and during the course of the night remarks included: 'I was in Egypt at the time, plotting the assassination of Nasser' and 'Wilson and Heath were destroyed in part by the action of intelligence agents' and (spoken with incredulity) 'You mean we shouldn't have got rid of Allende?' The hostility between just two of the participants, which often brings most life to the programme, occurred this time between Tony Benn and ex-CIA man Miles Copeland, and it was the fundamental difference in political outlook between these two which informed the entire discussion. Anyone who regarded Benn as a dangerous 'loony leftie' but watched right through until 2.00 may have been astonished at his thoroughly conservative British attitudes."
    Tony Benn wrote in his diary, later published as The End of an Era:
    "Saturday 13 May - In the evening I went to take part in this live television programme After Dark with John Underwood in the chair. It was an open-ended discussion which started at about midnight and went on till the early hours. The other participants were the historian Lord Dacre, Eddie Chapman, who had been a double agent during the war, Anthony Cavendish, who is a former MI6 and MI5 officer, Miles Copeland (an ex-CIA man), James Rusbridger, who has worked with MI5 at one stage, and Adela Gooch, a defence journalist from the Daily Telegraph. Every one of them made admissions or came out with most helpful information. I was terribly pleased with it."


    The Listener magazine described the programme:
    "The new Official Secrets Act has just received the Queen's assent. This may be the last time for some years that any disclosures can be made on such matters.... After Dark exists for mysterious reasons, probably something to do with a necessary safety-valve in a climate of increasing pressure on the media.... Its strength is that it has rescued that endangered species, genuinely spontaneous conversation, and presented it absolutely without frills. It does not have to rely on a presenter or on the glamour of its guests, as other talk shows do. Its force is its unique lack of inhibition in dealing with very controversial issues without exhibitionism...an invaluable programme. "


    Richard Norton-Taylor reported on guests who did not appear because of concerns about contempt of court:
    ""Michael Randle and Pat Pottle, who admitted helping the spy, George Blake, escape from prison in 1966... have been dropped from the... programme... Mr Randle and Mr Pottle were arrested and released on police bail last week after admitting in a book that they had helped Blake escape.'

    Open Media can be forgiven here of course - it was their production.

    Many years ago though we did ensure its safety for posterity in the Avalon Library, so this can be viewed here:

    Link: https://avalonlibrary.net/Tony_Benn_...ounds_1989.mp4

    “If a man does not keep pace with [fall into line with] his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer. Let him step to the music which he hears, however measured or far away.” - Thoreau

  10. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to Tintin For This Post:

    Brigantia (13th September 2022), Harmony (13th September 2022), Mare (13th September 2022), Mark (Star Mariner) (13th September 2022)

+ Reply to Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts