+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

  1. Link to Post #1
    Costa Rica Avalon Member
    Join Date
    13th February 2021
    Location
    In a Log Cabin in the Mountains
    Language
    English
    Posts
    270
    Thanks
    97
    Thanked 1,722 times in 250 posts

    Default A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    I’ve been working on re-translating the Barton Cylinder, which includes a Sumerian creation myth, for the past month. Sixty hours of dedicated work per week and I am still only two-thirds done, if that tells you anything about the complexity of the work involved.

    I found a great number of what I consider to be “sloppy” translations done to date, so I thought I should look at it further – and I am glad that I did. It will all become part of my upcoming book – “Our Governments Talk to Extraterrestrials, and They Have For Over 70 Years” – and this is the final chapter to be included in it. So I am working as fast as I can to get it done.

    The Barton Cylinder is a clay cylinder with Sumerian writing on it, dating to the mid to late 3rd millennium BC, which is now in the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology.

    The cylinder is inscribed with a Sumerian cuneiform mythological text, and it was found at the site of Nippur in 1889 during excavations conducted by the University of Pennsylvania. The cylinder takes its name from George Barton, who was the first to publish a transcription and translation of the text in 1918 in “Miscellaneous Babylonian Inscriptions”. Samuel Noah Kramer referred to it as The Nippur Cylinder and suggested it may date as far back as 2500 BC. From the sign choices employed and the terms themselves I believe that it was rewritten in 2500 or so but from much earlier materials. It references the earliest days, and the time prior to the Sumerians moving into the land between the rivers – so it’s the Origin story of the Sumerians themselves as well. It was probably originally recorded about 5500 BC, in my experience.

    One of the lines that I worked on nearly gave me a heart attack when I read the translation. Could this represent evidence of plagiarism on the part of the Biblical scholars?

    George Aaron Barton (12 November 1859 – 28 June 1942) was a Canadian author, Episcopal clergyman, and professor of Semitic languages and the history of religion. And he himself, in reference to his translation of this cylinder seal, believed that it was the source for some of the Biblical material written many thousands of years later. Barton goes so far as to suggest that several concepts within the text were later recycled in the much later biblical Book of Genesis. Barton also finds reference to the tree of life in the text, from which he claimed: “As it stands the passage seems to imply a knowledge on the part of the Babylonians of a story kindred to that of Genesis (Genesis 2:9) “.

    Most of the lines relate historical events, but some are simply “wisdom” text type entries, offering advice and suggestions on how to live and enjoy an upright life. These are similar to the sayings found in the Books of Psalms and Proverbs of the Old Testament. And the rest relate to the creation or origin of the Sumerian people and the creation of hybrid human-alien beings, but I must save most of that for the book.

    I’m interested in the truth more than sensationalism, so rather than putting this out as some type of evidence that the Bible authors knew the Sumerian texts and used parts of them for their books, in all fairness I am pointing out the opposite – because the truth is that the evidence shows this as resembling an amusing wisdom statement and not the origin of the Serpent and Eve in the tree of the Garden of Eden.

    Here is my actual source work, for you to examine and test as you wish. The Univ. of Pennsylvania has an online website with their Sumerian Dictionary project available to all, as does UCLA and Oxford, who offer their contributions to the total.

    This is the line 10 from Side A of the Cylinder text, in Sumerian:

    10. muš dam te esz2-mu-gin7

    And this is the “official” translation done by the scholars (the en: indicates their translation into “english”)

    en: like …

    So, that’s all they got from those six symbols of information. Sure. A meaning of “like …”, and nothing further. Well, they probably had the heart attack I got at first, and decided to back off and say nothing at all about the line. Apparently they decided to omit it from our knowledge, to create yet another “nothing to see here, move along” moment. But that’s not science, which should be, above all and foremost, about the truth. And here is that truth, in my own translation:

    There are six symbols, and the definitions of each of them I have taken from the Univ. of Penn, Oxford and UCLA publications themselves. All of these are peer-reviewed definitions.

    The note of “Ed IIIa” means that the definition comes from the period of Sumerian history that dates to the time of the suspected date of writing. Because if you accept meanings that were applied much later in time, you will not only be inaccurate but can be prosecuted for creating a timeline mismatch.

    muš ED IIIa, = “snake”.
    dam ED IIIa, = “spouse”.
    te as gal5 ED IIIa, = “a policeman; a demon”.
    eš2 = eše2 & še3 (same sign for both).
    še3 ED IIIa, = “to call by name”.
    eš2 ED IIIa, = “rope, thong, string”

    mu as geš ED IIIa, = “tree; wood; a description of animals”.
    mu ED IIIa, = “name; line of text; son” [lineage, ancestry, bloodline].

    gin7 = dim2 (same sign for both).
    dim2 ED IIIa, = “to create, fashion, make, to bring forth”.

    At first glance I took this as:
    SERPENT + SPOUSE + A DEMON it was called + TREE + TO CREATE – BRING FORTH

    And since this is a “creation” text, we can assume that the “to create, make, bring forth” indicates children, and especially since we have the optional meaning of name, line of text and son, which indicates lineage, ancestry, bloodline – the “lines of text” are mentions of actions accomplished by ancestors or living relatives. These deeds would become a future “line” in a text.

    So Barton thought it represented a source for the later Bible story, and here we have the wise and cunning serpent, the tree, the spouse (Eve) and a creation (child) who might represent a “demon” or bad seed. Like Cain?

    The reason I bring up Cain is that in Louis Ginzberg’s “The Legends of the Jews” it relates that the angel Samael, who is the great Satan, appeared to Eve after she and Adam had been expelled from the Garden of Eden. He came in the form of the serpent, and … well, you know the kind of things the world’s second human and a fallen angel in serpent form get up to.

    But here’s what I have found with experience: there is no such thing as an ‘accidental’ influence when it comes to society- simply unexpected ones. Thus the possibility that this mention in texts that were extant at the time may have “influenced” the later (by many thousands of years) Biblical events of Genesis is fairly plausible. But it does not signify a “theft” of another authors work.

    I should mention that, to the Sumerians, there were no demons. Demons are a Christian and Judaic term somewhat in align with the Jinn of Arabic mythology. To the Sumerians these were spirits, ghosts, phantoms, etc., the type of beings that could be called up by a trained person and questioned. Like the famous Witch of Endor did in the Old Testament.

    The Sumerians, as did the later Greeks, had their sky, atmosphere or upper regions, but not the “heaven” term that is understood today. And their “deities”, far from the Christian sense, were simply “sky beings” or “sky gods” if you will.

    But we can see why Barton, an Episcopal Minister but in his early life a Minister of the Quaker religion, might have added the term “demon” to the Sumerian Dictionary project.

    And here’s why that line does not equate to the Biblical Eden serpent idea, and what I believe is actually meant by it.

    For the Serpent’s wife: your children will be like the Ghost in the Tree.

    Thus this is a simple wisdom-type statement of advice, from an early Sumerian scribe.

    In other words, if you marry an evil or vicious person, a poisonous person we might say, then the children that you have together, rather than being memorialized on seals and on historical monuments, will be like Spirits in the Trees – scaring the little ones, but without the power to accomplish anything of substance themselves. They will not put brick upon brick, nor lead armies into battle – but will remain deplorable bullies, like their father.

    They will perhaps be remembered, but in an infamous rather than famous way. If you marry a powerful but evil person, don’t expect your children to be anything like a paragon of virtue – garbage in – garbage out, as we say in modern times.

    Truth is not about “fairness”, nor is about being sensitive to the “feelings” and “faith” of others – unless it conforms to the evidence. But whenever we do run across something that was obviously sidelined by traditional scholars who feared the consequences of revealing that truth, we should go as far as we can towards righting that wrong.

    I believe that the Bible does not need to be “protected” by our translators. Just read.

    Your own thoughts and comments are certainly appreciated.

  2. The Following 23 Users Say Thank You to Jim_Duyer For This Post:

    Arcturian108 (18th December 2021), Bill Ryan (18th December 2021), Bluegreen (19th December 2021), Brigantia (19th December 2021), ExomatrixTV (18th December 2021), Gwin Ru (18th December 2021), haroldsails (18th December 2021), Inversion (19th December 2021), Ioneo (18th December 2021), Jad (18th December 2021), Johan (Keyholder) (19th December 2021), Marbelo (19th December 2021), Mark (Star Mariner) (21st December 2021), mountain_jim (19th December 2021), Nasu (22nd December 2021), pabranno (18th December 2021), Pam (19th December 2021), Ratszinger (18th December 2021), Richard S. (19th December 2021), sijohn (20th December 2021), Siphonemis (21st December 2021), SpookyMulder (18th December 2021), Sunny-side-up (18th December 2021)

  3. Link to Post #2
    Avalon Member
    Join Date
    3rd July 2018
    Posts
    2,824
    Thanks
    19,444
    Thanked 22,359 times in 2,804 posts

    Default Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    ...

    ... thanks for the hard and arduous work!

    If you have not heard of him, you may be interested in the work of Russell Gmirkin who ends up concluding that most of the current bible was derived from Sumerian texts... translated into Greek... and only then... transcribed into Hebrew.

  4. The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to Gwin Ru For This Post:

    East Sun (18th December 2021), haroldsails (18th December 2021), Inversion (19th December 2021), mountain_jim (19th December 2021), Pam (19th December 2021), SpookyMulder (18th December 2021), Sunny-side-up (18th December 2021), Tyy1907 (19th December 2021)

  5. Link to Post #3
    Netherlands Avalon Member ExomatrixTV's Avatar
    Join Date
    23rd September 2011
    Location
    Netherlands
    Language
    English, Dutch, German, Limburgs
    Age
    56
    Posts
    12,534
    Thanks
    12,135
    Thanked 69,762 times in 11,314 posts

    Lightbulb Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    • William Bramley's The Gods of Eden - Commentary and Read by Josh Reeves (chapters 1 - 12):

    • 2 Gods Of Eden Author William Bramley interviewd by Linda:


    • William Bramley - Gods of Eden - Red Ice Radio:
    No need2follow anyone, only consider to broaden (y)our horizon of possibilities
    Dutch/English 🇳🇱 🇧🇪 🇺🇸 🇬🇧 🇦🇺 🇨🇮 🇨🇦: whynotnews.eu

  6. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to ExomatrixTV For This Post:

    Inversion (19th December 2021), Pam (19th December 2021), SpookyMulder (19th December 2021), Sunny-side-up (19th December 2021)

  7. Link to Post #4
    Costa Rica Avalon Member
    Join Date
    13th February 2021
    Location
    In a Log Cabin in the Mountains
    Language
    English
    Posts
    270
    Thanks
    97
    Thanked 1,722 times in 250 posts

    Default Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    Thanks for the kind words. I thought my book on Covid at 250 pages was a pile of work, but I am quickly learning that I may need to split the next one into two or three parts! But I hope to have it all done soon. I had not read Mr. Gmirkin, but I will - he's very correct in his conclusions, as far as my 12 years of study tells me. I gave it the benefit of the doubt - in addition to ancient Sumerian I also mastered proto-Hebrew. But the evidence is very strong - they were searching to make a name, and they were nomadic herders, so they had not a lot of choice except to borrow from the existing libraries.
    Update = sorry, checked out Gmirkin to some extent, and I can not agree with his idea of an invention of Plato. But I will still read what he has to say.
    Last edited by Jim_Duyer; 18th December 2021 at 23:49.

  8. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Jim_Duyer For This Post:

    Gwin Ru (19th December 2021), Inversion (19th December 2021), mountain_jim (19th December 2021), Pam (19th December 2021), SpookyMulder (19th December 2021), Sunny-side-up (19th December 2021)

  9. Link to Post #5
    Costa Rica Avalon Member
    Join Date
    13th February 2021
    Location
    In a Log Cabin in the Mountains
    Language
    English
    Posts
    270
    Thanks
    97
    Thanked 1,722 times in 250 posts

    Default Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    Quote Posted by ExomatrixTV (here)
    • William Bramley's The Gods of Eden - Commentary and Read by Josh Reeves (chapters 1 - 12):
    • 2 Gods Of Eden Author William Bramley interviewd by Linda:
    • William Bramley - Gods of Eden - Red Ice Radio:
    I recently learned that another author - Jim something or other, commented that Bramley took most of his info from the Church of Scientology. With their founders CIA and Naval Intelligence connections, it's not surprising that the govt. came to the same information as my many years of research did. I still like Bramley, who has since left the "Church". If not already I am sure to be on their list of outstanding humans, ha ha.
    His book dovetails with my research - which tells me that the Govt. does indeed know what I know, and used the Scientologists so that they could obtain their own source of "confessions" - jealous of the Catholics I imagine.
    Having Tom Cruise and others tell their deepest secrets has paid off I see - based on the latest politics.
    Bramley exhibits no obvious agendas - and I still tout his book whenever possible - it's a classic.

  10. The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to Jim_Duyer For This Post:

    Inversion (19th December 2021), mountain_jim (19th December 2021), Pam (19th December 2021), SpookyMulder (19th December 2021), Sunny-side-up (19th December 2021)

  11. Link to Post #6
    Costa Rica Avalon Member
    Join Date
    13th February 2021
    Location
    In a Log Cabin in the Mountains
    Language
    English
    Posts
    270
    Thanks
    97
    Thanked 1,722 times in 250 posts

    Default Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    I should relate that I have two sources of evidence in the form of the most ancient form of Sumerian writing - the pictographic type that was popular some three thousand and more years even before Cuneiform - that the Visitors did not create mankind, but rather created hybrids. They say "the good ones were taken back to the home system" and the other few remained in Sumerai. I know the two systems - one of the Goat people of Enlil (evil ones) and the other system of Enki and the Sheep group - the good guys. And I also know the planet that Enlil came from - all from their texts. I have also found support recently for my once hypothesis that the current visitors are "returning". So now its a full-fledged and evidenced theory. Interesting times coming very soon.

  12. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Jim_Duyer For This Post:

    Brigantia (20th December 2021), Gwin Ru (19th December 2021), Inversion (19th December 2021), mountain_jim (19th December 2021), SpookyMulder (19th December 2021), Sunny-side-up (19th December 2021)

  13. Link to Post #7
    Costa Rica Avalon Member
    Join Date
    13th February 2021
    Location
    In a Log Cabin in the Mountains
    Language
    English
    Posts
    270
    Thanks
    97
    Thanked 1,722 times in 250 posts

    Default Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    I won't bother to open another thread, since this is related to this same tablet translation.
    On one section it actually describes the sky-gods, and in that section they were referring to the evil group, which they refer to as "The Dark Ones". It's a fairly detailed description, from roughly 5000 BC, so it is interesting.

    You won't find too many images of Enkidu, the sidekick of Gilgamesh - they like to show you the ones where he looks very normal.

    But here is one that is earlier, and it looks very much like what the tablet describes:

    http://paleoaliens.com/enkidu.jpg

    And yes, he does have a weird angle to his arms and body stance, and yes he does look like the "lizard" people of Ubaid period, very close to the same era in Sumeria. So here we have direct evidence, textual in nature. of a lizard looking people connected to Enlil's group, the Dark Ones. However, they also say that the good ones connected to Enki were normal looking.

    Since they took the hybrids back to the planet group of origin, this begs the question of = how much would a human hybrid be worth on their local market, with the understanding that they might be able to change their future generations into something more resembling human beauty and not something under a rock?

    And of course, are they still doing this business?
    Last edited by Jim_Duyer; 19th December 2021 at 00:22.

  14. The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to Jim_Duyer For This Post:

    Brigantia (20th December 2021), ExomatrixTV (19th December 2021), Gwin Ru (19th December 2021), Inversion (19th December 2021), mountain_jim (19th December 2021), Pam (19th December 2021), SpookyMulder (19th December 2021), Sunny-side-up (19th December 2021)

  15. Link to Post #8
    Argentina Avalon Member Vicus's Avatar
    Join Date
    6th October 2020
    Location
    Europa
    Language
    Spanish
    Posts
    273
    Thanks
    4,118
    Thanked 2,009 times in 267 posts

    Default Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?


  16. The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to Vicus For This Post:

    Brigantia (20th December 2021), ExomatrixTV (23rd December 2021), Jim_Duyer (19th December 2021), mountain_jim (19th December 2021), Pam (19th December 2021), SpookyMulder (19th December 2021), Sunny-side-up (19th December 2021), The KMan (19th December 2021)

  17. Link to Post #9
    Avalon Member SpookyMulder's Avatar
    Join Date
    4th September 2011
    Location
    In the office dealing with Scully...
    Posts
    98
    Thanks
    1,304
    Thanked 798 times in 92 posts

    Default Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    Thank you Jim for the work you have started, it looks and sounds awesome.

    I just passed my copy of "gods of eden" to a dear Reiki Master friend of mine to add to her library as I did with many of other books. A library where others can borrow and read from, it's a classic.
    I have seen life on this planet, and that is exactly why I am looking elsewhere.

  18. The Following User Says Thank You to SpookyMulder For This Post:

    Sunny-side-up (20th December 2021)

  19. Link to Post #10
    Costa Rica Avalon Member
    Join Date
    13th February 2021
    Location
    In a Log Cabin in the Mountains
    Language
    English
    Posts
    270
    Thanks
    97
    Thanked 1,722 times in 250 posts

    Default Re: A Sumerian Garden of Eden story?

    Quote Posted by SpookyMulder (here)
    Thank you Jim for the work you have started, it looks and sounds awesome.

    I just passed my copy of "gods of eden" to a dear Reiki Master friend of mine to add to her library as I did with many of other books. A library where others can borrow and read from, it's a classic.
    You are most welcome - thanks for the kind words.
    Yes, it should be shared. I recommend it whenever I can.

    By the way - did you ever hear about how the author was attacked,
    by the powers that be? They certainly went out of their way to dig up
    some petty deal and make it into something much bigger - and yet at
    the same time they let people go without much punishment in Calif. ,
    unless it hits a soft spot.

  20. The Following User Says Thank You to Jim_Duyer For This Post:

    Sunny-side-up (20th December 2021)

+ Reply to Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts