Regarding Vanda Shiva of India, I sincerely applaud his/her efforts to spread knowledge on growing organically. I truly do . . . I hope many take heed and make the choice to be responsible for their own food.From a Google search for "Vandana Shiva of India": Environmental activist Vandana Shiva has been working to build an organic agriculture movement across India for the past 22 years. (www.worldwatch.org/node/6189)
Were you really curious as to what Vandana Shiva of India was doing, or were you just raising, again, your criticism of opposing without solutions?
But again my main point is this activist is only addressing the food production for a few. I am assuming because I have not read the material about this movement, but I don’t have to because . . . .again . . .. it is literally impossible to grow food organically or even naturally few millions of people. Please refer to post #17
So yes I am criticizing this movement of Vandana as a solution (for the billions of humans) because it does not address the feeding of the many . . . only a few. As a solution for the few it is dead on and commendable.
No . . . . I absolutely do believe Monsanto is necessary. With our current technology (engineered by Monsanto’s and subsidiaries) billions of people globally are being fed . . . including the majority of people on this forum.Ah - so you do NOT think Monsanto is necessary? You do oppose Monsanto, and you're just discussing how best to proceed?
... could'a fooled me .
And yes I do oppose Monsanto as an overall holistically healthy food, which is why I grow most of my own. It is far from it but, they are working through the problems and have come a far way since the 80’s
I would love to discuss how to proceed on a global basis and not only for small groups of people who are either able to buy organically raised food or grow it.
Dennis, currently Monsanto technology is the only technology that is absolutely feeding the world’s poor and even the wealthy (as a matter of fact)As far as I know, Monsanto made false claims about their GMO seeds having any actual benefits "to feed the world's poor." If you have seen (non-Monsanto funded) research that GMO seeds actually will feed the world, I'd love to read them
It is not WILL feed the world . . . .they are doing it NOW. Where do you think all the billions of tons of grains (corn, wheat, soy beans, rice) are going?
Aquaponics is a great way to grow food . . . on a small scale. But to put things into perspective . . .. Aquaponics on a larger scale is dependent on many types of ‘chemicals or additives’ in order for the plants to grow properly and one is also required to use ‘specially created’ seed and plant stock. So guess whose technology aquaponics can be traced back to?Aquaponics may be the only way the food industry can be localized. I'm not sure about how it could be applied to grains - though rice already grows in water...maybe there is potential here? The system has a range from house to backyard to farm size.
To be able to move forward in a balanced, pragmatic and productive way we first have to build a foundation from understanding and truth for ALL of humanity.
Not just ourselves or small groups. Organic and naturally farming is capable of feeding a few . . . . gmo farming is needed to feed the many.
I agree that we should be our brothers keeper . . . .but does that mean only a few brothers we can fit into our personal views and opinions or does our personal views, opinions and agendas take all the brothers into consideration?
Tough question isn’t it? So yes Paul I would love to discuss how to proceed for ALL my brothers and sisters globally.




Reply With Quote