Cargo Cult in the USA

[kfm27917]

Cargo cult: Why America cannot have nice things

https://asiatimes.com/2024/05/cargo-...e-nice-things/

According to media reports, the Biden administration is planning to announce 100% tariffs on imports of Chinese electric vehicles. The President needs to nail down the union vote and protect his right flank from “weak on China” accusations before November.

EV tariffs are a cheap solution to both problems. Americans won’t feel a thing. China exports a negligible number of cars to the US. Fat, stupid and happy – American life will carry on as if nothing happened.

The average price of a new vehicle in the US is US$48,000. In the Ford F-150 line-up, that’s a mid-range XLT variant. It’s a Toyota Crown in mid-level Nightshade trim.

And it’s a Tesla Model 3 with the long-range, dual motor, all-wheel drive package. These are all commendable vehicles and Americans should be the envy of the world for having such excellent motoring choices.

No… no they should not. Compared to what’s now on offer in China, Americans are paying outrageous prices for absolute dog piles. For $40,000, Chinese buyers can get a top-of-the-line Tesla Model S equivalent dual-motor 4WD BYD Han.

Hyundai cut prices on its Sonata sedan from $42,000 to $17,000. And for $11,000, Chinese consumers can buy a BYD Qin plug-in hybrid for less than half the US price of Toyota’s equivalent Corolla hybrid.

Biden’s saving grace is that most Americans do not know that they don’t have nice things. Few Americans lament the lack of high-speed rail. How can you miss what you never possessed?

If you’ve never experienced 300 Mbps download speeds, you won’t question AT&T marketing 100 Mbps as 5G. If every student goes $40,000 into debt to pay for college, it’s not considered a burden on America’s young.

New York City’s subway has always been like that. And if Chinese EVs are not available in the US, people will continue to buy $48,000 dog piles and like it.

Of course, the pretense can’t go on forever. There are intelligent well-traveled people in America who know what goes on in other parts of the world. Unfortunately, they haven’t had much success bringing those nice things home.

For decades, China has systematically on-shored the best the world has to offer. While still missing a few key pieces (cutting-edge chip fabs and commercial airplanes), the systematic process has been a spectacular success.

Cargo cults were religious movements in Pacific Melanesia where members aped the behavior of advanced societies in hopes of summoning valuable “cargo” to their islands.

This sometimes involved the construction of elaborate but comical copies of advanced technology and infrastructure like wooden airplanes and mock landing strips which always failed to achieve the desired effect.

Somewhere in the San Joaquin Valley of California sits 1,600 feet of a recently completed high-speed rail track which the California High-Speed Rail Authority proudly christened the “Fresno River Viaduct.” It took nine years to build and somehow cost $11 billion.

Two years after Congress allocated $7.5 billion to build 500,000 EV charging stations, seven have been completed. TSMC’s Arizona chip fab has been called a “debacle” by media outlet Rest of the World, rife with employee dissension, make-work and high turnover.

According to the WSJ, the Pentagon has sent thousands of military-grade drones to Ukraine only for them to be rejected in favor of cheaper and more reliable off-the-shelf models from China’s DJI.

Every naval strategist is advocating for a Whole of Government Effort (WOGE) to revitalize American shipbuilding, whose capacity has fallen to 0.4% of China’s. There are a lot of eggheads running around Washington these days advocating for WOGEs of all kinds.

This is across the political spectrum from clean energy WOGEs to military industrial base WOGEs to science and technology WOGEs to education reform WOGEs. WOGEs are all the rage and have been assigned magical properties by their advocates.

Anthropologists now dismiss the clownish “cargo cult” conceptualization as reductive. Traditional island cultures were crashing up against modern technology resulting in wrenching change and societal upheaval that only sometimes expressed themselves in comical ways.

Island societies were long led by “big men” who set agendas, doled out resources and settled disputes. Men who could not reciprocate in these social relations were considered “rubbish men.” When the modern world came crashing in with their “cargo”, island big men and all the favors they previously dispensed plummeted in value, making “rubbish men” of entire societies.

Social entrepreneurs emerged promising to summon valuable cargo, return the islands to a previous golden age and/or restore traditional morality. The silly airplanes, landing strips and control towers were a minor part of the movement, derogatorily hyped by Western snickering.

Ultimately, “cargo cults” were attempting to establish new political relationships and hierarchies in societies upended by sudden contact with the modern world.

Han Feizi has some sympathy for the California High-Speed Rail Authority and the Washington WOGE activists on a sociological level. How different, after all, are cargo cults from Qing Dynasty boxers who waged a heroic but futile rebellion against foreign occupiers?

Sympathy cannot, however, override the fact that cargo cults were a blind alley for the Melanesians as they groped their way toward joining the modern world, just as the Boxer Rebellion made things worse for Qing Dynasty China.

A budget and a mandate is as useless for building high-speed rail as a thatch and wood airplane is for delivering cargo if the commission responsible refuses help from experts in the field. Just as transitioning America to clean energy isn’t made easier by blocking the lowest cost and most advanced products from American markets.

To be sure, Han Feizi understands why massive tariffs are being implemented. Without them, American car companies will not survive the decade. The economic and societal fallout of losing such a pivotal industry is unfathomable.

This, of course, has been the justification for multiple “just this once” bailouts of the industry from the “chicken tax” on imported pickup trucks to guaranteed loans to export quotas on Japanese cars to more guaranteed loans to EV subsidies to, now, 100% tariffs on Chinese EVs.

It begs the question of why General Motors, Ford, Jeep/Dodge and Tesla are reporting massive profits while Americans suffer a cost of living crisis, not helped by $50,000 pick-up trucks with $12,000 margins?

It begs the question why Ford and GM were allowed to return $12 billion and $18 billion to investors respectively through massive share buybacks over the last decade on top of generous dividends?

General Motors, Ford and Jeep/Dodge have shown no ability to rise to the occasion and have never been held accountable for squandering decades of government largesse.

Expecting the Big Three to catch up to China’s EVs under government protection is cargo cult behavior which will become increasingly obvious as consumers in the Global South start driving better cars than Americans.

The US successfully twisted Japan’s arm in the 1990s, forcing them to build local factories. China forced all multinationals to manufacture domestically through local JVs. The US, however, might not be able to pull off something similar this time around.

The US has not been the world’s largest car market for 15 years, selling only half as many units as China. And not just China – the Global South now buys three times as many cars as the US. America, as they say, will not be negotiating from a position of strength.

It is also entirely unclear whether politicians will trust Chinese cars – even when made in the US – fearing millions of spies on wheels rolling through American streets.

Bytedance’s experience with TikTok should give Chinese automakers pause; after achieving mass adoption and dazzling success, politicians moved in for the steal. For 13% of global markets (6% excluding pickup trucks), is it worth the aggravation?

According to political scientist Mancur Olson, democracies are not equipped to resist policies where the benefits are concentrated but costs dispersed.

The 100% tariff on Chinese EVs will likely become another sedimentary layer of inefficiency that accumulates in the late-stage democracy politically captured by interest groups.

The chances of Detroit rising to the occasional are, let’s face it folks, similar to the chance of California completing the high-speed rail project ahead of schedule and under budget.

Cargo cults no longer exist in Melanesia. It was an unfortunate but perhaps unavoidable phase for a society upended by modernity. China’s Boxers fortified themselves for their rebellion through mystical practices which made them impervious to bullets. It didn’t work.

Every society must cross its river of denial and pain to reach the shores of modernity. America is no exception.

[onawah]

What the Chinese already know and the rest of the world may soon discover-- EVs made in China are shoddy and likely to catch fire and explode.

Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=DR5BOl8aglI

Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=zS6dwGFv5HI

Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=tXZqrTORdho

Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=DwhnArkZTu8

[onawah]

China's economy and overall society are far from stable not to mention its "tofu dreg" infrastructure.
Flooding, sinking, and other environmental catastrophes are on the rise and export performance suffers as well.

China's Fragile Economy Behind Latest Data; CCP Admits Safety Risks In 13,000 Dams
China Truths
May 13, 2024

China Releases April Trade Data, Exposing Four Major Economic Issues
Rare Event in Beijing: Red Aurora Seen for First Time in 20 Years
Chinese Media Exposes: 13,000 Dams in China Pose Safety Risks
Gold Prices Like a Rollercoaster: Numerous Gold Shops and Recyclers in China Close Down
Thousands Join New York Parade to Celebrate World Falun Dafa Day, Reject Communism
37.7K subscribers

Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=lqUAUCQfTdI

Overly optimistic expectations of exports has led to incredible waste:

Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=1SEfwoqKRU8

Source: https://youtube.com/watch?v=ANxfOmJGeFc

[palehorse]

Posted by onawah (here)
What the Chinese already know and the rest of the world may soon discover-- EVs made in China are shoddy and likely to catch fire and explode.

WOW!!! that is outrageous! few BYD on the streets here, they all belong to those Chinese expats, my tactics to scare them out is just to hit the gas pedal when in traffic, the black smoke at 3k rpm is unbelievable (sorry i couldn't resist, and i have to clean my pipes soon) lol

[Jim_Duyer]

Well, the OP certainly loves all things China, it seems. Where to begin?
We don't have the long-distance high-speed rail because we have too many towns in between - unlike Canada where you can ride one to view the wilderness. That and the fact that our railroad owners were mostly robber barons.
A BYD is a car or truck that you can admire as they explode on the docks while awaiting shipment - I saw a video with 100 or so of them going up at the same time. Incredible pieces of Crap. They sell them in Central America, and if you go by the dealerships you can see the taillights filled with water - yes, after a good rain these brand new "vehicles" leak water right into the taillights and elsewhere.
The only and I mean only way that they can sell them is with their no-down-payment and low interest loans from the manufacturer - any decent local bank will hardly loan on them due to their life expectancy being less than the terms of the loan.
Yes, American vehicles are overpriced now - thanks to unions and the tactics they use to force car companies to pay those who got out of high school only because the standards were lowered the same wage that a beginner Doctor makes - ridiculously overpaid, and they finally got the rewards of their greed - closing factories, unprofitable vehicles, more robots for workers, etc.

Yes, the Ukraine takes Biden's money and then uses it to buy Chinese - but that's because he can pocket the difference after sending their cut back to the PTB in the States. Hardly a fair comparison of economic choices.

If you like Chinese EVs and BYD in particular - pick a part. Any part. And then go first to the dealer that had the nerve to sell you that junk and then to every parts dealer you know and see if you can even buy a replacement. Chances are you will not be able to. The dealers only stock enough to get the crap off the lot and out of the 30 day guarantee - after that it's your problem. Real car companies, even Japanese and Koreans, stock parts for purchasers.

Yes, Chinese shipbuilders are flourishing, just like their car manufacturers. And they fall apart, but nobody seems to care as long as they are cheap to purchase. Most of the ones that you read about today that crash and burn were built in China. Good luck with that.

First - climate change, global warming - whatever the current name is, is a farce, and most scientists know this. Yes, the weather changes, but arctic ice levels are at the highest in 20 years, and no water from melting burgs has covered key west as of yesterday, nor New York or London, so I call BS. AND if you really want to lump irony upon irony, please, I beg you, use Google to do a search on the manufacturing centers of those EV crap machines - you may not see them at first due to all of the smoke and pollution they spew out. Absolutely more than the USA, Britain and Europe combined. Taking out Chinese crap manufacturers would go further to slow pollution and any farcical warming than anything the USA could ever do.
In short, it's a scam, led by traitors, encouraged by greed, supported by dummies who buy the stuff, and built proudly in China.
Or am I too harsh?