+ Reply to Thread
Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 1 3
Results 41 to 42 of 42

Thread: The cost of medical care in the US -- way out of line

  1. Link to Post #41
    Avalon Member happyexpat's Avatar
    Join Date
    1st December 2010
    Location
    Mostly Disinterested Enlightenment
    Age
    51
    Posts
    223
    Thanks
    418
    Thanked 621 times in 170 posts

    Default Re: The cost of medical care in the US -- way out of line

    Quote Posted by Flash (here)
    Yes, for foreigners, it is the full price, no government coverage (like in Britain), therefore 3,500$ to set foot in an hospital, but not for a Canadian (i do not understand that you would have paid that in Ontario when Quebec plan has agreement with all the other Canadian provinces for Quebec citizens).
    I've never had papers for Quebec citizen... Wasn't eligible for OHIP yet at the time.

  2. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to happyexpat For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (9th October 2026), Harmony (9th October 2026)

  3. Link to Post #42
    United States Avalon Member RunningDeer's Avatar
    Join Date
    6th February 2012
    Location
    Forest Dweller
    Language
    English
    Age
    76
    Posts
    20,123
    Thanks
    138,335
    Thanked 185,043 times in 19,939 posts

    Default Re: The cost of medical care in the US -- way out of line

    Surgeon Reveals Why You Don't Need Health Insurance
    • Dr. Elisabeth Potter, MD
    • September 22, 2026
    • 132K subscribers
    When Dr. Elisabeth Potter scrubbed out of surgery to take a call from UnitedHealthcare, she had no idea it would change her life. The patient in question was already under anesthesia, mid-mastectomy, and the insurer wanted her to justify an overnight hospital stay on the spot. They denied it anyway, and the patient was billed $100,000. Potter's video about that moment was watched by more than 26 million people, and it was followed by a cease-and-desist letter from a powerful Washington, D.C. law firm demanding she retract everything.

    In this episode, Louisa sits down with the Austin-based reconstructive microsurgeon to unpack what really happens between a diagnosis and the care patients actually receive. She explains why she believes denial is a strategy, how prior authorizations, peer-to-peer calls, and appeals work in practice, and why roughly 1 in 5 in-network recommendations on some Affordable Care Act plans are rejected. She shares why a procedure she has performed for 14 years is still labelled "experimental," the year-long fight to get one young woman a mastectomy, and why a single billing code values a muscle-sacrificing TRAM flap the same as the muscle-sparing DIEP flap she specializes in.

    You'll also hear what DIEP flap reconstruction involves and why she prefers it to implants for many patients, the personal cost of standing up to an insurance giant, including draining her savings and risking bankruptcy to keep her practice open, and the advocacy that followed, from a rally in Washington, D.C. to the Speak Free Act and the Patients Deserve Price Tags Act. She reveals how one hospital quoted a patient $240,000 for a surgery she could perform for $17,000, and lays out exactly what patients can do right now: record every appointment, demand an itemized estimate, and appeal everything.

    Finally, she delivers the truth she feels morally obligated to tell every American: insurance isn't what you think it is, and you don't actually need it to get good care.

    TOPICS DISCUSSED
    00:00 Intro: "You Don't Actually Need Insurance"
    01:01 The Call From UnitedHealthcare in the Middle of Surgery
    04:02 The Three-Minute Phone Call Outside the OR
    05:47 Why Denial Is a Strategy
    07:34 Justifying an Overnight Stay for a Patient Under Anesthesia
    09:37 The Video That Reached 26 Million People
    11:39 The Cease-and-Desist Letter
    12:22 What the Comments Revealed About America
    14:36 Does She Regret Taking On UnitedHealthcare?
    15:15 What Happened to the Patient's $100,000 Bill
    16:20 Going Into Debt to Keep Her Practice Open
    20:09 How the US Two-Tier Healthcare System Works
    21:26 Who Else Is in the Room With You and Your Doctor
    22:04 Why a 14-Year-Old Procedure Is Still Called "Experimental"
    23:44 Peer-to-Peer Calls and Hours Lost on the Phone
    24:50 Denial Rates: 1 in 5 Recommendations Rejected
    25:46 Why There Are Only a Few Hundred True Reconstruction Specialists
    27:14 What DIEP Flap Breast Reconstruction Is
    29:15 Breast Implants vs DIEP Flaps
    31:07 When Your Body Has Something to Offer You
    32:26 A Year and a Half On: Washington, FIGS, and the Speak Free Act
    34:47 How Denials, Prior Authorizations, and Appeals Work
    36:47 A Year-Long Fight for One Woman's Mastectomy
    38:28 Billing Codes: Why TRAM and DIEP Flaps Are Paid the Same
    41:50 What She Would Tell UnitedHealthcare's CEO
    43:16 The Biggest Obstacle to Patient Outcomes Is the System
    45:03 One Diagnosis Away From Bankruptcy
    47:28 Protect Yourself: Record Every Appointment
    49:10 Ask for an Itemized Estimate: $240,000 vs $17,000
    50:46 Where the Money Goes and the Patients Deserve Price Tags Act
    52:27 Appeal Everything: Specialty-Matched and Expedited
    53:55 Why Doctors Can No Longer Stay Silent About Money
    54:43 Her 60-Second Truth: "You've Been Fooled"
    56:19 How to Support the Fight


    AI Key Points
    • Insurance is not the same as access to healthcare. Insurance coverage does not guarantee that patients will receive the treatments their doctors recommend, and healthcare can be delivered through providers and facilities without insurance determining every decision.
    • UnitedHealthcare contacted Potter during surgery. While she was performing a series of operations, an insurance representative called about a patient who was already under anesthesia for a mastectomy and awaiting breast reconstruction.
    • The patient had prior authorization. Despite the advance authorization and the patient's breast cancer and lung abscess, the insurer required Potter to justify why the patient needed to stay overnight.
    • The overnight stay was denied. The patient received a $100,000 bill, which was erased after the incident attracted public attention.
    • Denial can reduce insurance spending. Patients facing serious illnesses may lack the time, energy, resources, or emotional capacity to challenge denied treatments, allowing denials to go uncontested.
    • The incident exposed a disconnect between insurers and patients. The representative could not provide basic information about the patient's diagnosis and referred Potter to another department, reinforcing concerns about fragmented decision-making.
    • The viral video generated widespread attention. Potter posted a video describing the experience after finishing her surgical cases. It reached approximately 26 million viewers and prompted responses from patients, doctors, and others with similar experiences.
    • Potter received a cease-and-desist letter. UnitedHealthcare sent a legal letter demanding that she retract statements, remove the video, and address allegations concerning her conduct and the video's comments.
    • Public reactions reflected widespread frustration. Comments revealed anger and cynicism about insurance companies, including reactions to the killing of a former insurance CEO. Potter condemned murder while viewing the responses as evidence of the distress people experience when navigating healthcare.
    • Advocacy threatened Potter's financial stability. She used retirement savings, sold possessions, and accumulated substantial debt to keep her practice open, continuing to provide breast reconstruction services despite the risk of bankruptcy.
    • The US healthcare system lacks a consistent safety net. Unlike systems that guarantee a baseline level of care, access in the United States can vary according to insurance contracts, coverage rules, and patients' financial circumstances.
    • Insurance companies influence treatment decisions through coverage determinations. Prior authorization, billing codes, policy exclusions, and classifications such as “experimental” can prevent recommended treatments even when doctors believe evidence supports them.
    • Appeals consume significant time and resources. Potter described a team member spending five hours on the phone to arrange a peer-to-peer discussion about a procedure, while other cases required repeated calls and lengthy appeals.
    • Denials can delay essential treatment. Potter cited a young woman with breast cancer, a genetic mutation, and a strong family history who waited nearly a year for approval to remove both breasts. After repeated calls, an insurance-company oncologist approved the surgery, and Potter completed bilateral breast reconstruction.
    • Insurance denial rates can be substantial. Potter cited Affordable Care Act plans with in-network denial rates reaching approximately 20%, meaning roughly one in five submitted recommendations may be rejected in some plans.
    • DIEP flap reconstruction uses a patient's own tissue. Potter transfers tissue from the abdomen to create a living breast supplied by blood flow. She contrasts this with implants, which can rupture and cause complications, and TRAM flap reconstruction, which removes abdominal muscle and can impair core strength. She generally recommends evaluating implant replacement around the 10- to 12-year mark.
    • Reimbursement systems can discourage better surgical techniques. Potter explained that the same CPT code, 19364, covers both TRAM and DIEP flap breast reconstruction despite their differences. She argues that reimbursement should recognize techniques that preserve muscle and improve patient outcomes.
    • Healthcare price transparency is a major priority. Potter described a case in which a hospital quoted $240,000 for surgery while her own surgery center estimated $17,000 for the same patient, surgeon, and geographic area. She supports the Patients Deserve Price Tags Act to improve access to itemized estimates and bills.
    • Patients can take practical steps to protect themselves. Potter recommends recording medical appointments where legally permitted, requesting clinic notes and copies of orders, obtaining billing codes, asking for complete itemized estimates, comparing providers, and appealing denials. Appeals should request a specialty-matched reviewer and expedited consideration when appropriate; patients can also pursue external appeals.
    • Systemic reform requires public participation. Potter supports the proposed Speak Free Act, developed with assistance from FIGS, and urges Americans to contact their members of Congress and senators to support the Patients Deserve Price Tags Act. She advocates a system with government-supported baseline healthcare, greater price transparency, accountability, and competitive care outside insurance, emphasizing that doctors must address the financial structures affecting their patients.

  4. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to RunningDeer For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (9th October 2026), Ewan (9th October 2026), grapevine (9th October 2026), Harmony (9th October 2026), Sue (Ayt) (9th October 2026), Sunray (9th October 2026)

+ Reply to Thread
Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 1 3

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts