Posted by Milneman
(here)
Posted by Sidney
(here)
Another reason for lack of memory of past lives could be that this is indeed a persons first trip here. Also some peoples brains are more efficient than others. We aren't suppose to remember because we were set up for failure to do so, having been wiped of memories between lives.
I also think it may be possible that not everyone is reincarnated, that at death, it is indeed the end. I don't really go along with that theory but in truth the possibilities are endless. I personally think reincarnation is really the only thing that makes sense.
Really?
Let me float something over and see what you think.
Consider the possibility that the universe has an infinitely powerful being operating it. Thought experiment, so go with me for a moment. Consider that being "thinks" every sentient being into existence, and that being that is thought into existence will continue to exist as a thought in that infinitely powerful being. So when you die, your physical body dies but the essence of what you are (soul) continues to exist on and on.
The major argument against this possibility that I hear usually comes in the form of "Wouldn't you get bored living in eternity, doing the same things over and over and over?" And my reply to that is this: suppose that infinitely powerful being operates the universe, exists outside of the universe, and outside of time. Suppose that as you exit this universe, you exit the confines of what time is. How, then do you determine when you get bored of doing something if there is no time to do it in?
Thinking this way, let's put another layer into the experiment. Suppose that infinitely powerful being notices that certain energies have qualities that help the system, or are used by the being as a means of regulating the system somehow. Constants, let's call them. Suppose that some energies (let's call them souls) do in fact manifest differently than others for this exact reason. Again, this is a thought experiment and not meant to promote a certain dogma, but what if the idea of angelic beings actually gets a twist from this notion?
So now we have a simple system on the scale of the entire universe, controlled by an infinitely powerful being, using certain elements to re-condition the system because they have a greater potential.
Suppose there's a system in place in the universe to allow for the development of the life which inhabits the universe to grow, develop, and mature within the system? Let's call it natural selection and modern evolutionary theory. Suppose the next stage in human evolution, in this thought experiment, is recognizing the choice to evolve to the next point. Suppose that's the point of it all.
Doesn't that make as much sense as a system that continually recycles itself? You also have the problem of explaining how a system like reincarnation begins. If we've always existed, always will exist, and always will continue to exist, when were we created? How were we created?
Going with my own thought experiment, which in part is belief for me, I end up at the exact same questions someone who believes in reincarnation does. And that's interesting, don't you think? It means, somewhere along the line, aspects of what we both believe are true...or we are both equally deceived!
Sidney, I'm not suggesting you're wrong in what you believe. I think for whatever reason you're justified in your beliefs, and that's cool! You have a right to be, just as much as I have a right to be. The problem for me begins when another belief system, with equal value, can somehow be dismissed slight of hand without substantial proofs.
Anyway, happy Friday.