+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2
Results 21 to 40 of 40

Thread: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

  1. Link to Post #21
    Honored, Retired Member. Hervé passed on 13 November 2024.
    Join Date
    3rd July 2018
    Posts
    4,691
    Thanks
    46,568
    Thanked 35,412 times in 4,672 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    ...

    ... this could be a solution to counter that same very global application being fostered on humanity to keep it on its knees:

    Quote "People will let themselves be led by someone who is in the next level up on the scale. Therefore, all of the gullible souls in the Fear band can be easily influenced and pushed into action by the 1.5 (anger fixation)."--Ruth Minshull (How to choose your people p119)
    Source: http://whale.to/v/tone.html

  2. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Gwin Ru For This Post:

    arwen (25th July 2023), Bill Ryan (13th December 2022), Harmony (25th July 2023), Icare (23rd April 2023), petra (9th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (13th December 2022)

  3. Link to Post #22
    UK Avalon Member Matthew's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th July 2015
    Location
    South East England
    Language
    English
    Age
    53
    Posts
    4,641
    Thanks
    28,205
    Thanked 40,149 times in 4,579 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    If you don't think you're influencing anyone then tough luck you are anyway. If you're trying to influence you probably aren't.

  4. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Matthew For This Post:

    arwen (25th July 2023), Bill Ryan (14th December 2022), Harmony (25th July 2023), Icare (23rd April 2023), petra (9th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (13th December 2022)

  5. Link to Post #23
    United States Avalon Member Casey Claar's Avatar
    Join Date
    26th April 2022
    Location
    San Diego, CA
    Language
    English
    Age
    61
    Posts
    1,371
    Thanks
    7,888
    Thanked 13,057 times in 1,370 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    Quote Posted by Bill Ryan (here)
    Quote Posted by Gwin Ru (here)
    Quote Posted by Bill Ryan (here)
    ... Discuss.
    cough-cough... what for?
    Made me laugh.

    It really seemed to me to be one of those paradoxes (or anomalies) that we never discuss at all. It comes a little close, maybe, to being an Emperor's New Clothes type of thing.

    There are zillions of examples all over social media, but let's just take the microcosm of the Avalon forum. Below are some of the issues sometimes fiercely discussed in the last few years.

    The vast majority of posters on these subjects already have fairly (or very) well-set views, and the number of instances of someone saying [something like] "Hey thanks, I see your point of view, you've explained it very well, and I think I've changed my mind" is tiny.
    • Vaccine effectiveness
    • Ivermectin effectiveness as a covid treatment
    • Trump's legacy as US president
    • Biden's legacy as US president
    • QAnon's claims and statements
    • Global warming
    • Ukraine/US vs Donbass/Russia.
    There are many more, but those come to mind immediately.

    What I notice again and again is that exchanges between those with opposing views get nowhere at all. It often comes close to literally being a waste of time.

    So that leads to the question: What's the value of exchanging opinions?

    I might suggest the answer: Much less than we may assume.

    So what's the value of discussing anything at all?

    I think the true value — which is important and significant — actually lies in expanding the nuances of our understanding of issues we broadly already agree with. As a kind of crude metaphor, we're educating one another about geophysics, not arguing about whether the earth is spherical or not. We're way past that point now.

    And here's a very real example, not a metaphor at all. I'm personally as sure as I can be that a lost major civilization, probably a global one, existed prior to about 12,500 years ago. What I am interested in reading about and learning much more about is the ongoing discovery of artifacts and other evidence that may tell us more about what the civilization was like, where and when it flourished, and what eventually became of it.

    And the same for the existence of ETs, UFOs, and off-planet (or maybe interdimensional) civilizations that are interacting with us on Earth. I'm 100% certain this is all very real. But I still want to learn more about the possible details, agendas, history, phenomena, and so on.

    So there's an important distinction that can be made about the kinds of information we're all sharing here every day — and why we're sharing that information at all.

    Here's a thought experiment. We've not had this happen on Avalon yet, but supposing a new member appears who starts advocating some of the aspects of 'woke' culture that I'd suspect many (or most, or maybe all!) of those reading this would consider abhorrent, socially destructive, and maybe even a symptom of a kind of modern mental illness.

    Do we allow them a platform to express their views?

    If your view is 'yes' — then why??
    I will dive in here:

    "So that leads to the question: What's the value of exchanging opinions?"

    Is it opinions we are really sharing? I would suggest we are sharing much more than this, something far more intimate, either knowingly or unknowingly. We are sharing ourself. The value of this comes in the doing. Doesn't it? In the process of this we refine ourselves. It is quite the cooking process, isn't it? But the refinement can somewhat easily be seen and understood by considering first a more feral kind of man and situating this alongside any one of us, anyone who has learned how to express themselves, share of themselves, including the exchange of raw information. The value is that through this we evolve, both as an individual and as a species.

    Quote "I think the true value — which is important and significant — actually lies in expanding the nuances of our understanding of issues we broadly already agree with. As a kind of crude metaphor, we're educating one another about geophysics, not arguing about whether the earth is spherical or not. We're way past that point now."
    I would go significantly further.

    I think we learn - grow - very little, relatively speaking, in a petrie dish of those we are already in agreement with. I do agree, as you have said, Bill, that what can be learned are ever greater nuances and intricacies, however only of a SINGLE color, rather than all color. I think the really important thing we are all learning is not a view, or even spectrum views, but how to allow these to peacefully coexist. How to not go to war against 'other' views, nor run from, segregate, demonize, marginalize or omit them. This is what I think, as a species we are at the cusp of learning. How to do this. How to live, breathe, think and behave in harmony with ALL that is. It is a process, though, and beginning with a solid basis in understanding ourself, even deep down into all those nuances is a good, intelligent and profound start. The immanent question is, how will this progress? Does a sports team, as an example, ever get any better playing against itself? - ( answer : it doesn't ).

    Quote "Here's a thought experiment. We've not had this happen on Avalon yet, but supposing a new member appears who starts advocating some of the aspects of 'woke' culture that I'd suspect many (or most, or maybe all!) of those reading this would consider abhorrent, socially destructive, and maybe even a symptom of a kind of modern mental illness.

    Do we allow them a platform to express their views?

    If your view is 'yes' — then why??"
    My answer would be yes.

    Not just yes but a resounding yes.

    There really is room enough for everyone. Understanding our own processes is one thing, but it is only a start. Evolving ourselves to truly ( and by this I mean accurately ) understand someone else, their processes, where they are in their own unfoldment is another. As is not interfering or impeding upon that. One very large reason we are seeing what we are in the world at present, is that good people, positively oriented people are inclining toward negative thought, action and behavior. The [ + ] orientation is one of inclusion, allowance, and non-infringement upon free-will. It is the [ - ] orientation that fights, dominates, disallows and infringes. Those who have chosen the [ + ] orientation, and in my estimation this is 92+% of the local population have to focus more into the fact of their choice and spend more of their time actively developing it.

    This indeed is what will turn the tides. ( clearly, yes? ).

    Practice is required. So, yes, open the stage.

    Always trust in the potential of an open and pure heart. <-- let Avalon be where this is developed.

    Nothing can overrun or overturn this. Save ourselves.

    Is our love strong enough?

    Let's run the LIVE test.
    "Love is what is left when you let go of everything you no longer need." —Raj

  6. The Following 9 Users Say Thank You to Casey Claar For This Post:

    arwen (25th July 2023), Bill Ryan (14th December 2022), edina (20th December 2022), Harmony (25th July 2023), Icare (23rd April 2023), Pam (25th July 2023), petra (9th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (14th December 2022), T Smith (14th December 2022)

  7. Link to Post #24
    Avalon Member Digit's Avatar
    Join Date
    18th April 2023
    Location
    Earth, Sol star system, for now.
    Language
    netspeak
    Posts
    14
    Thanks
    28
    Thanked 87 times in 13 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    Jumping straight in to offer initial response to:

    Quote Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    ... Discuss.
    Perhaps "rarely", but not never.
    So there's a chance.

    However, perhaps it's better to approach with some kind of epistemological method, than reliance on mere guesstimation of statistical chance.

    Maybe I'm yet to discover an even better method. Or even just need to better practice.

    I've still a long way to go at reliably deploying a warm, inviting, curiosity-evoking version of the socratic method. But I think it's good to keep trying to develop. Any other ideas how?

    Also, which social media?

    I suspect one can find different results, on, say, diaspora than mastodon. Different results on GNU Social compared to Zot. And even differences between different servers in the same protocols, e.g. catcatnya (mastodon fork with long form) compared to any more w.h.o. censorship adherent mastodon servers. And between anything of the fediverse and corporate social media. ... I'm just presuming with that last one... I don't do corporate social media. I just presume it's a very high probability of low caliber mind apertures among those who stayed on The Corporation's casino-like addictive datamining & censorship sites.

    It's fun to seek out different perspectives. Approach them with your mind open, and more likely to garner similar in return.

    [Edit:
    PS: regarding:
    Quote
    • Vaccine effectiveness
    • Ivermectin effectiveness as a covid treatment
    • Trump's legacy as US president
    • Biden's legacy as US president
    • QAnon's claims and statements
    • Global warming
    • Ukraine/US vs Donbass/Russia.
    I've expanded my conceptions of all of these, learned much from others, and usually, it goes unsaid, the learning and delving into more nuance, continuing after whatever helpful pointers/seeds/clues/links shared in some post on the fediverse.

    So keep offering good offerings. You may never know how many storms you whip up, by flapping your butterfly wings. ]
    Last edited by Digit; 23rd April 2023 at 18:30.
    If ignorance is bliss, give me agony. (&, The ignorance that dies, is not you.)
    Time flies when you’re not in pain or prison. We are psychenauts, and we are not afraid.
    Educate yourself so you may educate others.

  8. The Following 10 Users Say Thank You to Digit For This Post:

    Akasha (30th August 2023), arwen (25th July 2023), Bill Ryan (23rd April 2023), grapevine (25th July 2023), Harmony (25th July 2023), Icare (23rd April 2023), Pam (25th July 2023), petra (9th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (25th April 2023), Tintin (25th July 2023)

  9. Link to Post #25
    Avalon Member
    Join Date
    24th January 2011
    Posts
    993
    Thanks
    4,122
    Thanked 5,034 times in 865 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    Quote Posted by sunwings (here)
    One of the reasons that social media may not be effective at changing people's minds is that it can be a echo chamber, where people are exposed primarily to views and opinions that align with their own. This can create a biased and skewed view of reality, and it may make it difficult for people to consider alternative perspectives. Additionally, people may be more likely to engage with content on social media that confirms their existing beliefs, rather than content that challenges or contradicts those beliefs.

    Chat GPT
    I don't fault what you have posted but from my point of view .... people seldom change their current indoctrination!

    I was a .... well lets say 'mod' on a well known forum and I near never saw members 'change their mind' because of the posts created by other members!

    Never happened. (<< and that is over years)

    The alternative community will cling on to an idea or concept (disregarding most all negative information to their held belief) as badly as the mass of people!

    There isn't really much of a distinction between the mass and the alternative (<< sorry I know how that reads ... but it would seem to be correct? I am happy to be wrong!)
    Normal..!

  10. The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to lake For This Post:

    arwen (25th July 2023), Bill Ryan (23rd April 2023), grapevine (25th July 2023), Harmony (25th July 2023), Icare (23rd April 2023), Pam (25th July 2023), petra (9th November 2026), Tintin (25th July 2023)

  11. Link to Post #26
    UK Avalon Founder Bill Ryan's Avatar
    Join Date
    7th February 2010
    Location
    Ecuador
    Posts
    40,386
    Thanks
    301,240
    Thanked 533,840 times in 38,926 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.


  12. The Following 10 Users Say Thank You to Bill Ryan For This Post:

    arwen (25th July 2023), avid (26th July 2023), grapevine (25th July 2023), Harmony (25th July 2023), Mark (Star Mariner) (25th July 2023), Matthew (25th July 2023), Pam (25th July 2023), petra (9th November 2026), Tintin (25th July 2023), Yoda (25th July 2023)

  13. Link to Post #27
    Australia Moderator Harmony's Avatar
    Join Date
    11th May 2020
    Language
    English
    Posts
    3,823
    Thanks
    139,229
    Thanked 26,625 times in 3,819 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    My observation is people posting on PA like to offer information for others to contemplate, join dots or maybe delete them thus forming a bigger picture of what is going on around us. Rather than changing minds I think our overview evolves. Adding more understanding of how things unfold, which is really quite complex, sometimes helps us develop compassion and love as well.



    If we can understand how things happen, we have the power to change them or not repeat them again. I really like perusing new ideas or information, just putting them on the back burner for later where they often fit in the puzzle of life somewhere.

  14. The Following 15 Users Say Thank You to Harmony For This Post:

    Akasha (30th August 2023), arwen (25th July 2023), avid (26th July 2023), Bill Ryan (25th July 2023), Delight (25th July 2023), Ernie Nemeth (25th July 2023), Ewan (25th July 2023), grapevine (8th September 2024), Isserley (25th July 2023), JackMcThorn (25th July 2023), Mark (Star Mariner) (25th July 2023), Matthew (25th July 2023), petra (9th November 2026), RunningDeer (29th August 2025), Tintin (25th July 2023)

  15. Link to Post #28
    Avalon Member arwen's Avatar
    Join Date
    16th December 2014
    Posts
    798
    Thanks
    5,497
    Thanked 8,424 times in 796 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    I remember clearly the early days of the Usenet. 1994 - 1995 for me.

    I remember engaging in exciting discussion with people all over the world, using the Deja News bulletins boards to find areas of mutual interest.

    I remember the AMAZING level of high quality conversations. The early pioneers were those kinds of people. Curious, open to debate, new ideas, civil.

    Then came the masses. Then came the World Wide Web. Then came trolls and spam and bots to disrupt conversations and amplify emotions. Then came social media to corral the anarchic Usenet groups into controllable echo chambers. Then came intelligence agency and government covert influence campaigns with massive budgets.

    So given all that, nope, mostly nobody will change anyone's mind on anything unless they are all mutually agreed to share ideas and learn from each other.

    The Internet was and has been such a magnificent gift - in the beginning, it lead to exponential evolution in human communication. It honestly worked better in terms of exchange of ideas and opinions and useful discourse back in the days of the Usenet. Social Media was deliberately structured in my opinion to default to the lowest common denominator. But one can still use it strategically to enjoy the original benefit - filtering out noise and antagonists and tuning into what is valuable.

    Avalon is thus an oasis, reminiscent of the old Usenet, where quality conversations on a variety of really interesting topics take place. Disruptions are occasional, and able to be managed BECAUSE of the Moderators, to whom we all owe a great gratitude and appreciation for their time.

    In my humble opinion. You do not have to agree with me.
    Last edited by arwen; 25th July 2023 at 16:14.

  16. The Following 10 Users Say Thank You to arwen For This Post:

    Akasha (30th August 2023), Bill Ryan (26th July 2023), Delight (25th July 2023), Ewan (25th July 2023), grapevine (25th July 2023), Harmony (26th July 2023), Mari (8th September 2024), Matthew (25th July 2023), petra (9th November 2026), triquetra (30th August 2023)

  17. Link to Post #29
    UK Avalon Member Matthew's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th July 2015
    Location
    South East England
    Language
    English
    Age
    53
    Posts
    4,641
    Thanks
    28,205
    Thanked 40,149 times in 4,579 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it read and accept your tweet deep into its soul. Social media is a useful echo chamber because news travels fast, it's digested across a wide demography and feedback is near instantaneous. It's a fantastic echo chamber, ...so useful! Is anyone influenced by anything? Other than the bombardment of advertising, trash tv and state fear? I'm not sure. More than five years ago I guess, but those who are transformed didn't transform by me giving them a 10 minute rant monologue about virus theory vs 5G. Their trust was broken, it had little to do with me.

  18. The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to Matthew For This Post:

    Akasha (30th August 2023), arwen (25th July 2023), Bill Ryan (26th July 2023), Ewan (8th September 2024), grapevine (25th July 2023), Harmony (26th July 2023), Mari (8th September 2024), petra (9th November 2026)

  19. Link to Post #30
    Avalon Member triquetra's Avatar
    Join Date
    2nd February 2015
    Posts
    380
    Thanks
    233
    Thanked 1,860 times in 365 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    The difference is like navigating a hall of mirrors alone, compared with navigating a labyrinth together with everyone of a like mind to your own across the entire world.

    Everyone has taken themselves up with the hall of mirrors, caught up in the fast moving bouncing of light that is over and over again just a reflection of themselves, each direction looking equally viable as the last.

    Few have remembered that in places like Avalon, you CAN navigate the labyrinth (and even the abyss) through what you have learned from your comrades as you work together. Even as some of us have found dead ends, we are able to communicate them to one another to better find our way together.

    Maybe most people on Earth needed to become even more lost before they could find themselves again through cooperative discussion, rather than freezing themselves in place, arguing (to themselves) that their determined path through the hall of mirrors is the right one. When a social network is really just a way of funnelling data to the company that runs the network, and interacting with others is just an illusion in order to reinforce the ego and generate even more data for the company in your thrashing about, that's all that can really happen.

  20. The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to triquetra For This Post:

    Akasha (30th August 2023), Bill Ryan (30th August 2023), Delight (30th August 2023), grapevine (8th September 2024), Harmony (30th August 2023), pabranno (30th August 2023), petra (9th November 2026), Vangelo (30th August 2023)

  21. Link to Post #31
    Germany Avalon Member SoulValor's Avatar
    Join Date
    28th December 2021
    Location
    Germany
    Language
    German
    Posts
    62
    Thanks
    43
    Thanked 589 times in 61 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    I don't think online discussions should have the premise of changing other people's minds. How about just sharing experiences, views, information and data and see where that leads to? No need for proselytisations or the involvment of egos. Nobody needs to believe anything or convince anybody or get convinced.

    Maybe it's just about sharing and broadening one's horizon, regardless of it fitting your current world view or not....and isn't it more fun to question things, including yourself and your own views? And consider/delve into other possibilities even if they sound crazy at first? I wish more people would get into that groove....

  22. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to SoulValor For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (8th September 2024), grapevine (8th September 2024), Harmony (11th September 2024), Orph (8th September 2024), petra (9th November 2026), shaberon (8th September 2024)

  23. Link to Post #32
    United States Avalon Member
    Join Date
    1st April 2016
    Posts
    7,125
    Thanks
    36,343
    Thanked 40,768 times in 6,774 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    Quote Posted by SoulValor (here)
    I don't think online discussions should have the premise of changing other people's minds. How about just sharing experiences...

    I would say those are two different kinds of conversations.

    And, this is definitely on a scale...there are those who believe it their duty to compel you to believe.

    There are those who refuse to affect anyone whatsoever.

    As someone who is notoriously impossible to affect, I only have one example about "change". I'm not sure I "changed my mind" (switched sides), but, discovered a new idea.

    I am guessing the context of *most* of what is being discussed is more along the lines of persuasion, that is, propaganda which has the intent of affecting the way one feels and transferring reputation to a different role model. We may be saying no one's propaganda works. It's a yelling of slogans.

    In the sense that there probably is "new information", something objective that I did not know or understand, then, yes, I hope I am at least adaptable and able to respond.

    When I started posting here, I may have been asking a wrong question.

    It turns out to be a federal government issue.

    I found someone posting something that "sounded" like the issues I had in mind. So I asked a lot of questions. I spent some time with this, because, there was a coherent point being made, and I couldn't quite tell what it was. It took a little time and I got the feeling that some of the responses were a bit copy-paste off a website or someone's personal files. Fixed, pre-arranged. Not *quite* an in-the-moment spontaneous reaction.

    After learning the argument, I continued to post it on my own.

    Nobody ever particularly agreed or disagreed with the point being made, although sometimes there were reactions.

    A bit further down the road, I guess I figured out how to ask the "right question" and uncovered a series of facts that annihilate the argument.

    Naturally, I tried to feed this back into the original discussion and of course it did not go well. I got a few blunt dismissals and absenteeism. Apparently couldn't stand the heat. I don't know. I consider the thing resolved. Later, Bill banned this member in full public view for, what I would agree, were some very crude racist remarks.

    I "changed my mind", temporarily, I'm sure I did that. That was the universe's opportunity to adjust whatever was needed, and, it wound up being the negative of what it first looked like.


    At the same time, it would be most honest to say that I constantly give off rhetorical persuasion, that almost certainly is pre-loaded with certain values, and there is no chance I am un-biased. That's strongly the case. It's not a political party or form of government. The only thing I have really been known for is changing people permanently. I'm not sure I can even do anything else. The online experience is not "normal" like this. The third dimension remains superior.

  24. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to shaberon For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (8th September 2024), grapevine (8th September 2024), Harmony (11th September 2024), petra (9th November 2026)

  25. Link to Post #33
    Canada Avalon Member Ernie Nemeth's Avatar
    Join Date
    25th January 2011
    Location
    Toronto
    Age
    68
    Posts
    6,163
    Thanks
    28,048
    Thanked 40,989 times in 5,889 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    I have changed a handful of people's minds over the years, but not on a forum. It is only possible in an ongoing, real time, one on one, conversation. Some it took many years, first to teach what they did not know, then to correct their incorrect assumptions. Only after that can true learning begin. Every one has thanked me afterwards.

    And I come here with the same thing in mind, only in reverse. I thought I came here to teach, but in fact I came here to learn.

    Avalon has done for me what I did for those few.

    Some things have been harder to learn than others, and there are some things I have yet to learn, but I try my best to remain open. Some things seem as though I will never learn it, whether because they are not true or because I have a cherished bias I have yet to unravel.


    My other point is that I am very much aware of another reality that we do not understand and that is counter in many ways to this life. When discussing any topic I am fully aware that the topic is moot on this mysterious level of reality, yet I go on and on, pretending like the topic can stand on its own - when it can't.

    This other reality is far more real to me than this world. Much of what seems controversial in my posts is the realization that the topic under scrutiny has no merit in the real world. I am forever aware that we are living a lie, a false reality based on false assumptions about self hood. I understand we support a death cult that has inverted our world to cherish death and live life as though we are dead, only to finally come alive after we have died to this reality. It is preposterous and extremely frustrating.


    So yes, social discussions where more than two people are involved, and with no direct contact other than a screen, can never be adequate to change someone's mind.
    Too many voices, too many opinions, too many choices.
    Empty your mind, be formless, shapeless — like water...Now water can flow or it can crash. Be water, my friend. Bruce Lee

    Free will can only be as free as the mind that conceives it.

  26. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Ernie Nemeth For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (10th September 2024), Ewan (9th November 2026), Harmony (11th September 2024), Mike (11th November 2026), petra (9th November 2026), shaberon (11th September 2024)

  27. Link to Post #34
    UK Avalon Founder Bill Ryan's Avatar
    Join Date
    7th February 2010
    Location
    Ecuador
    Posts
    40,386
    Thanks
    301,240
    Thanked 533,840 times in 38,926 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.


  28. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Bill Ryan For This Post:

    Arcturian108 (9th November 2026), Harmony (9th November 2026), Mike (9th November 2026), petra (9th November 2026), shaberon (9th November 2026), Yoda (9th November 2026)

  29. Link to Post #35
    Canada Avalon Member
    Join Date
    7th July 2016
    Location
    Newfoundland, Canada
    Age
    46
    Posts
    3,869
    Thanks
    11,747
    Thanked 9,201 times in 2,900 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    Quote Posted by Bill Ryan (here)
    Quote Posted by Gwin Ru (here)
    Quote Posted by Bill Ryan (here)
    ... Discuss.
    cough-cough... what for?
    Made me laugh.

    It really seemed to me to be one of those paradoxes (or anomalies) that we never discuss at all. It comes a little close, maybe, to being an Emperor's New Clothes type of thing.

    There are zillions of examples all over social media, but let's just take the microcosm of the Avalon forum. Below are some of the issues sometimes fiercely discussed in the last few years.

    The vast majority of posters on these subjects already have fairly (or very) well-set views, and the number of instances of someone saying [something like] "Hey thanks, I see your point of view, you've explained it very well, and I think I've changed my mind" is tiny.
    • Vaccine effectiveness
    • Ivermectin effectiveness as a covid treatment
    • Trump's legacy as US president
    • Biden's legacy as US president
    • QAnon's claims and statements
    • Global warming
    • Ukraine/US vs Donbass/Russia.
    There are many more, but those come to mind immediately.

    What I notice again and again is that exchanges between those with opposing views get nowhere at all. It often comes close to literally being a waste of time.

    So that leads to the question: What's the value of exchanging opinions?

    I might suggest the answer: Much less than we may assume.

    So what's the value of discussing anything at all?

    I think the true value — which is important and significant — actually lies in expanding the nuances of our understanding of issues we broadly already agree with. As a kind of crude metaphor, we're educating one another about geophysics, not arguing about whether the earth is spherical or not. We're way past that point now.

    And here's a very real example, not a metaphor at all. I'm personally as sure as I can be that a lost major civilization, probably a global one, existed prior to about 12,500 years ago. What I am interested in reading about and learning much more about is the ongoing discovery of artifacts and other evidence that may tell us more about what the civilization was like, where and when it flourished, and what eventually became of it.

    And the same for the existence of ETs, UFOs, and off-planet (or maybe interdimensional) civilizations that are interacting with us on Earth. I'm 100% certain this is all very real. But I still want to learn more about the possible details, agendas, history, phenomena, and so on.

    So there's an important distinction that can be made about the kinds of information we're all sharing here every day — and why we're sharing that information at all.

    Here's a thought experiment. We've not had this happen on Avalon yet, but supposing a new member appears who starts advocating some of the aspects of 'woke' culture that I'd suspect many (or most, or maybe all!) of those reading this would consider abhorrent, socially destructive, and maybe even a symptom of a kind of modern mental illness.

    Do we allow them a platform to express their views?

    If your view is 'yes' — then why??
    That was funny. What for? Haha

    So, my view is Yes and here is why. This is a spiritual war we are fighting and sometimes we need to do it with words. Gentle words but still words. That would be something I would like to see and perhaps even participate in. Who knows maybe I might agree with them. I had to fight on a world of Warcraft forum about the existence of God before. The whole community was watching and it was epic. I feel bad that I was winning because we were friends in real life too. He was an Agnostic Athiest but I also think he was searching for God, and so that's why I argued with him for so long.

    You say social media rarely changes people's minds and I think you're right about that, no one takes social media seriously anyways. PA is different.

    My thoughts? Everybody is too nice sometimes. Just tell it to me like you see it.. that's what I want to hear.

  30. The Following 7 Users Say Thank You to petra For This Post:

    AutumnW (9th November 2026), Bill Ryan (9th November 2026), grapevine (11th November 2026), Harmony (11th November 2026), Mike (11th November 2026), shaberon (9th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (10th November 2026)

  31. Link to Post #36
    United States Avalon Member
    Join Date
    1st April 2016
    Posts
    7,125
    Thanks
    36,343
    Thanked 40,768 times in 6,774 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    Quote Posted by petra (here)
    Just tell it to me like you see it.. that's what I want to hear.

    So you say we are fighting.

    That might be closer to the thing. And in that sense, what is posted is perhaps more like boundaries and rules on how do you protect yourself from me.

    What kind of differences and disagreements can we live with without conflict?

    There's a lot that can be ignored, simply due to lack of interest, but on the other hand, I don't like working against an organized machine that grows a cult of drones, which I am mostly actually surrounded by.

    For example, you may have noticed years of diatribe leading to our Midterms, and then, when the rug gets swept away, suddenly there is nothing about it here.

    Instead, you'll see a re-launch by the losing party, attempting to save its reputation, to convince you of something worthwhile about it, and, on my part, I don't care to go through it any more. There's no discussion. Already, rather than changing anyone's mind, it achieved true repellence on its own.

    Because this is an irreconcilable difference in world views, the naivete' of trying to change something about it is a waste of energy. I find myself in general agreement with what looked to be Avalon's founding document, that is, a dread of an anti-Iran campaign and the consequences thereof, and so I'm actually a little surprised that anyone would come in to undermine the main mission, aiming rhetoric at me or anyone else who shared the point.

    My mind is always entirely changeable, given some workable input, but for the most part, I take corrections on sometimes not using the best expressions, or minor facts like the actual minimum wage in 1970, so, yes, it's a public forum and if you want to post those kinds of "rebuttals", then I will usually change it graciously. But those are mostly small details, not "my mind" as an operating system.

  32. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to shaberon For This Post:

    AutumnW (9th November 2026), Bill Ryan (9th November 2026), grapevine (11th November 2026), Harmony (11th November 2026), Mike (11th November 2026), petra (9th November 2026)

  33. Link to Post #37
    Canada Avalon Member
    Join Date
    4th November 2012
    Posts
    3,387
    Thanks
    7,136
    Thanked 15,178 times in 3,035 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    Social media is a poor fit for purely rational thought as it literally capitalizes on a strong emotional responses, particularly a strong initial response to a video or text, when the watcher, reader has no personal experience or familiarity with the subject, to counter the message.

    It turns most people into hyper reactive, shrieking baboons who stick to their own colonies, too afraid to venture out of them.

  34. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to AutumnW For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (9th November 2026), Harmony (11th November 2026), Mike (11th November 2026), onawah (11th November 2026), petra (9th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (10th November 2026)

  35. Link to Post #38
    Avalon Member sdv's Avatar
    Join Date
    5th March 2012
    Location
    On a farm in the Klein Karoo
    Posts
    1,508
    Thanks
    5,547
    Thanked 7,095 times in 1,377 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    I did change my mind about the 'cabal' or 'global controllers'. Over the years I have come across many witness testimonies that did not pass the smell test for me, and too often those stories resembled Hollywood movies, closely.

    It was the Gaza genocide that was a turning point for me, in a strange way. I got angry ... don't talk about abstract global controllers (various terms are used) when there is a genocide being conducted and supported in many ways. It is time for triage, not an abstract discussion!

    But that led me to read posts and join dots and find more credible sources, which may not talk about the issue directly but I started to see the multi-layered and interconnected threads. I became, and remain, curious and am grateful that there is some credible information that requires a deep dive, here on PA.

    Politics is a game, and it requires you to pick a team on an issue, and then support and defend your team, no matter what they do. Politics is not the real story. It is a manipulation, which is very useful for 'the controllers', because brainwashed people are useful to them?

    Just putting this out there ... I am happily brainwashed about being against cultural dominance to the extent of destroying cultures, war, genocide, murder, deliberately starving people, financially exploiting and engineering conflict in countries to do so, etc. ...!
    Sandie
    Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known. (Carl Sagan)

  36. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to sdv For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (11th November 2026), grapevine (11th November 2026), Harmony (11th November 2026), Mike (11th November 2026), onawah (11th November 2026), petra (11th November 2026)

  37. Link to Post #39
    Avalon Member sdv's Avatar
    Join Date
    5th March 2012
    Location
    On a farm in the Klein Karoo
    Posts
    1,508
    Thanks
    5,547
    Thanked 7,095 times in 1,377 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    I am not sure if this fits here, because stupidity is not an answer to why someone disagrees with you, but the theory does explain why people can be locked into a belief that is irrational, and that this is not an indicator of intelligence. Highly intelligent people can hold irrational beliefs.

    Summaries provided by Gemini ...

    This video explores Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s Theory of Stupidity, a concept developed during his time in Nazi Germany. The creator examines the idea that stupidity—defined not as a lack of intellectual capacity, but as a deliberate refusal to think and a tendency toward conformism—is a more dangerous threat to society than malice or evil.

    Key themes include:

    The Nature of Stupidity: How ordinary people can become dangerous by surrendering their critical thinking and autonomy to mass movements.
    Historical Context: Analyzing the climate of Nazi Germany through Bonhoeffer’s philosophical lens.
    Philosophical Connections: Exploring how Stoic philosophy provides a framework for maintaining individual agency and ethical responsibility in the face of societal pressure.

    The video serves as a modern reflection on personal accountability and the importance of independent thought in preserving freedom.

    Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s Theory of Stupidity argues that stupidity is a more dangerous enemy to the good than malice. He suggests that while one can protest against evil or use force to stop it, one is defenseless against stupidity because it is not primarily an intellectual defect, but a moral one.

    Key aspects of his theory include:

    Refusal to Think: Stupidity is not a lack of intelligence; it is a voluntary surrender of independent judgment. People become "stupid" when they conform to a group, ideology, or authority, effectively shutting down their own critical thinking.
    The Role of Social Pressure: This phenomenon often manifests in environments where individuals feel overwhelmed by external power or societal shifts. In such states, individuals abandon their autonomy to align with a prevailing movement, making them susceptible to being used as tools for dangerous agendas.
    Incurability through Reason: Because the stupid person is deeply satisfied with their own justifications and insulated from reality by their group identity, they cannot be reached by logical arguments or facts alone.

    Bonhoeffer, a German theologian who resisted the Nazi regime, wrote these reflections as a way to understand how ordinary people could participate in systemic evil by simply refusing to exercise their own conscience.

    Sandie
    Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known. (Carl Sagan)

  38. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to sdv For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (11th November 2026), Ewan (11th November 2026), grapevine (11th November 2026), Mike (11th November 2026), onawah (11th November 2026), petra (11th November 2026)

  39. Link to Post #40
    United States Avalon Member Mike's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th January 2011
    Location
    journeying to the end of the night
    Age
    49
    Posts
    6,966
    Thanks
    43,213
    Thanked 61,919 times in 6,877 posts

    Default Re: Social media discussion rarely changes anyone's minds.

    Social media rarely changes anyone's minds...initially. Some people do change their minds but it's a slow process, like turning a battleship around.

    I never thought of Avalon as social media but it actually is. Nothing wrong with that. Lots of good things about social media when it's done right. Youtube is also, technically speaking, social media.

    Social media is responsible for me changing my mind on all sorts of things. Ive changed my mind about guns, Trump, religion, abortion, marriage, patriotism, among other things.

    I remember changing my mind about guns in a discussion with former member TargeT. I was anti-gun, very emotional about it, and i just KNEW I was right, even if I couldn't justify it intellectually. And he just calmly dissected all my arguments. It was infuriating. But it was such a valuable lesson, because I can now easily see others trapped in that same game and i know when ive fallen into it again. It's an emotional game mainly, but if you can humble yourself for just a moment and calm down, there's massive growth waiting around the corner.

    I was anti Trump back in 2016. I was just mindlessly repeating everything they said about him in the press, and feeling very clever about it (..that he's racist, xenophobic, etc). I think it was Calz who interrupted that thought loop (thanks Calz). And after he helped create that little bit of space I was able to think for myself.

    I was pro abortion and regarded things like marriage skeptically. I had a very smug and condescending attitude towards religion. It was Herve who changed all that. He posted a thread about Jordan Peterson, who later turned out to be a massive influence on me, and i changed my mind on all those things.

    This is just the tip of the iceberg. Ive changed my mind on ufo's, abductions, numerous whistleblowers, and a whole host of other stuff.
    Last edited by Mike; 11th November 2026 at 13:56.

  40. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Mike For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (11th November 2026), Ewan (11th November 2026), grapevine (11th November 2026), onawah (11th November 2026), petra (11th November 2026), Tintin (11th November 2026)

+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 1 2

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts