+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 19 of 19

Thread: The Ethos of the New State

  1. Link to Post #1
    Germany Avalon Member Michi's Avatar
    Join Date
    17th April 2015
    Location
    Reinbek, Germany
    Language
    German
    Posts
    674
    Thanks
    5,388
    Thanked 5,193 times in 652 posts

    Exclamation The Ethos of the New State

    We can discuss all day here at PA and until the cows come home or the moon turns blue but our civilization will go nowhere unless some key changes takes place in our society:

    The basic flaw is that uneducated masses are electing uneducated charismatic leaders (Hitler, Obama, etc.) who answer to lobbyists who are then in turn battle for the greatest power.

    That doesn't mean that democracy is bad but as it is used (the larger number of ignorant people are putting the schmucks into power) is a dead-sure (pun-intended) way of failure.

    Our only salvation lays in having highly educated geniuses at the top who as a council are in charge for different aspects of the society.

    The following video shows how that could look like:



    "The West will require a significant evolution – to switch its idea of politics from that of narrow party politics within a dogmatically accepted, ossified political infrastructure, from political theatre and gossip, to a new phase of political theory that doesn’t merely switch parties but rewrites constitutions, doesn’t merely vote in stewards of the status quo but empowers leaders as intelligent political theorists who themselves define the values, mission and concepts of their ever-evolving State. Imagine if we had leaders that were required to pass a test on political philosophy, history, ethics and civics in order to get into power." – David Sinclair
    "The greatest good you can do for another is not just share your riches, but to reveal to him his own."
    -- Benjamin Disraeli

  2. The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to Michi For This Post:

    Arcturian108 (8th November 2026), Bill Ryan (7th November 2026), DNA (7th November 2026), grapevine (7th November 2026), Mike (7th November 2026), rgray222 (7th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (7th November 2026), Tintin (8th November 2026)

  3. Link to Post #2
    Avalon Member rgray222's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th September 2010
    Language
    English
    Posts
    3,772
    Thanks
    15,124
    Thanked 34,473 times in 3,661 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Michi, I agree we need major changes in our world. Before I say more, though, I’d like to understand whether this video reflects how you think the world should move forward: Do you truly believe that the world should create one world government that engages in unapologetic social engineering, places sovereign power in the hands of a small group of intellectual elites, removes religion, and prioritizes general intelligence above all else?

    I appreciate that you’re proposing something concrete; most people call for change without offering any specific ideas of what should actually be done. But this proposal is so extreme that it makes me wonder how serious you are about it.

  4. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to rgray222 For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (7th November 2026), DNA (7th November 2026), grapevine (7th November 2026), Michi (7th November 2026), Mike (7th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (7th November 2026)

  5. Link to Post #3
    United States Avalon Member Mike's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th January 2011
    Location
    journeying to the end of the night
    Age
    49
    Posts
    6,963
    Thanks
    43,182
    Thanked 61,888 times in 6,873 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by rgray222 (here)
    Michi, I agree we need major changes in our world. Before I say more, though, I’d like to understand whether this video reflects how you think the world should move forward: Do you truly believe that the world should create one world government that engages in unapologetic social engineering, places sovereign power in the hands of a small group of intellectual elites, removes religion, and prioritizes general intelligence above all else?

    I appreciate that you’re proposing something concrete; most people call for change without offering any specific ideas of what should actually be done. But this proposal is so extreme that it makes me wonder how serious you are about it.



    It sounds like she wants to turn the world into an ivy league campus.

    I don't know how a political/economic system can be both merit-based and redistributive (socialist) in nature. Someone explain pls?

    Geniuses and academics are often terrible social/political advisors. Look at someone like Neil Degrasse Tyson for example. Have you heard this "genius" offer his takes on culture and politics? Or Sam Harris? Or pretty much anyone on a college campus?

    Leadership requires a different kind of genius. One involving a high IQ, yes, but also one informed by a regular life among the people. A class of secluded elites without real-world experience is a recipe for breeding contempt for the average man

    And who decides which "elites" are going to rule? And without a system of checks and balances, what's to stop these elites from becoming tyrants? And without an orientation towards God, where does its morality come from?
    Last edited by Mike; 7th November 2026 at 02:24.

  6. The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to Mike For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (7th November 2026), DNA (7th November 2026), grapevine (7th November 2026), Michi (7th November 2026), rgray222 (7th November 2026)

  7. Link to Post #4
    UK Avalon Member samsdice's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th February 2015
    Location
    Southport
    Age
    66
    Posts
    156
    Thanks
    1,042
    Thanked 1,336 times in 154 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    And then there was AI. A common notion in many scifi books is a society that is run by AI. I suspect we'll eventually drift into a form of this. But I'm sure there will still be "politicians" as they would not be able to resist the lure of this "glamour profession".

  8. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to samsdice For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (7th November 2026), DNA (7th November 2026), grapevine (7th November 2026), rgray222 (8th November 2026)

  9. Link to Post #5
    United States Avalon Member DNA's Avatar
    Join Date
    8th May 2011
    Location
    S.W. Missouri
    Language
    English
    Age
    54
    Posts
    5,032
    Thanks
    37,858
    Thanked 31,922 times in 4,742 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by Michi (here)
    We can discuss all day here at PA and until the cows come home or the moon turns blue but our civilization will go nowhere unless some key changes takes place in our society:

    The basic flaw is that uneducated masses are electing uneducated charismatic leaders (Hitler, Obama, etc.) who answer to lobbyists who are then in turn battle for the greatest power.

    That doesn't mean that democracy is bad but as it is used (the larger number of ignorant people are putting the schmucks into power) is a dead-sure (pun-intended) way of failure.

    Our only salvation lays in having highly educated geniuses at the top who as a council are in charge for different aspects of the society.

    ir
    You are very correct.
    I'm of the opinion that the warping of the minds and indoctrination of the youth may be the greatest danger our country has ever faced.

    I say we all move to Ecuador and start a shanty town in Bill's front yard.
    I kid of course but the situation is dire.

    After reading Mike's post I agree with him as well.
    Although I will add we need the effing truth to be told.

    We can't go anywhere until the masses understand the truth
    And in my opinion that means understanding the Israeli zionist mechanism controlling the country.
    Last edited by DNA; 7th November 2026 at 14:51.

  10. The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to DNA For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (7th November 2026), grapevine (7th November 2026), Michi (7th November 2026), Mike (7th November 2026), rgray222 (8th November 2026)

  11. Link to Post #6
    Germany Avalon Member Michi's Avatar
    Join Date
    17th April 2015
    Location
    Reinbek, Germany
    Language
    German
    Posts
    674
    Thanks
    5,388
    Thanked 5,193 times in 652 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by rgray222 (here)
    Michi, I agree we need major changes in our world. Before I say more, though, I’d like to understand whether this video reflects how you think the world should move forward: Do you truly believe that the world should create one world government that engages in unapologetic social engineering, places sovereign power in the hands of a small group of intellectual elites, removes religion, and prioritizes general intelligence above all else?

    I appreciate that you’re proposing something concrete; most people call for change without offering any specific ideas of what should actually be done. But this proposal is so extreme that it makes me wonder how serious you are about it.
    Well - this video portrays drastic measures and I am not certain, if this is the only or perfect state. For example, the above video doesn't touch on nature and animals. So - how would that be integrated and how about those (like Bill) who prefer a life in nature - in some distance to overcrowded cities.
    I would subscribe to a meritocracy system and to have highly educated councils who actually advance the society and such councils must inherently self-correct with quality control.
    Citizens also actively participate in that quality control. (Perhaps similar to open source models.)
    "The greatest good you can do for another is not just share your riches, but to reveal to him his own."
    -- Benjamin Disraeli

  12. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to Michi For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (7th November 2026), DNA (7th November 2026), Mike (7th November 2026), rgray222 (8th November 2026)

  13. Link to Post #7
    UK Avalon Member Mike Gorman's Avatar
    Join Date
    31st May 2010
    Location
    Perth, Western Australia
    Language
    English
    Age
    68
    Posts
    2,335
    Thanks
    7,422
    Thanked 18,659 times in 2,215 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    The idea of having a Philosopher King based government I am sure has arisen before, but yes I know it seems eminently rational to have actually enlightened/intelligent people to manage and guide the world...it makes sense! However, what worries me is that we are not governed by politicians, we are too often beguiled by personalities ( Hitler, Trump, Churchill, Eisenhour e.t.c) that these are the true seats of power, when they are not: some may be more able to leverage power more than others, but it is another faction/caste/entity that truly governs the planet - Oligarchs, upper echelon groups that covertly rule. If this was a simple case of choose the right people, Democratic choice I would say yes, of course - but there are other aspects to this, some of it relates to economic dominance, ownership of resources, military might, but call me a true conspiracy theorist if you will, I just don't believe it has ever been about the right choice of politics, other forces are in play that confound our rational views on this.
    The outcomes of history are not just about human choices, or prosaic options.

  14. The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to Mike Gorman For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (8th November 2026), Michi (10th November 2026), Mike (8th November 2026), rgray222 (8th November 2026), samsdice (8th November 2026)

  15. Link to Post #8
    United States Avalon Member Ratszinger's Avatar
    Join Date
    9th September 2018
    Posts
    1,623
    Thanks
    2,233
    Thanked 10,874 times in 1,572 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Concentrated expert power has a poor track record of self-correction. Therefore, I would argue that the real political question is not “who should rule?” but “how do the so called uneducated masses remove very educated intelligent bad rulers without bloodshed?”
    Also, realizing Obama's education is questionable, Barack Obama is a poor illustration of “uneducated charismatic leader.” The official standing for his education is that he graduated from Columbia, then Harvard Law magna cum laude, and was elected president of the Harvard Law Review.⁠ Whatever one thinks of his policies or style, “uneducated” does not fit. I do not feel that a 'expert led' or dominant system of government would function well in democrasies and it would trample rights of the citizens in time as the 'expert educated' class took hold. Currently Singapore's system of governance follows this 'expert' or genius leader type of system in certain areas. It has not outperformed our type of system.
    The genius consistently stands out from the masses in that he unconsciously anticipates truths of which the population as a whole only later becomes conscious! Speech-circa 1937

  16. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to Ratszinger For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (8th November 2026), Michi (10th November 2026), Mike (8th November 2026), rgray222 (8th November 2026)

  17. Link to Post #9
    United States Avalon Member
    Join Date
    1st April 2016
    Posts
    7,117
    Thanks
    36,296
    Thanked 40,738 times in 6,766 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Constitutions do not carry instructions for their replacement; you have to dispose of whatever enshrines it. There have been something like eight Frances since the nineteenth century.

    When referring to the west, generally, it is inherently and permanently flawed, because it is just oligarchy.

    I would not willingly enter a social contract that does not reflect Hammurabi or India's Fish Justice, i. e., that the only valid role of government is to protect the small from the powerful.

    What we have mocks you by stifling most change by having a Senate and Supreme Court at the top of the decision-making process. Moreover, a vote was a principle to sweep away hereditary aristocracy, to replace nobility with financial oligarchy. Educated or Enlightened Monarchs, an Enlightened Despot, could perhaps be preferable. But the west was mostly run by Divine Right kings, which is the opposite; he owns the people like chattel. Other systems would prevent him from owning private property, and force national well-being as his job, such that revolts as are being seen in Europe are failure.

    Some education is in fact bad, since Economics will teach you how to increase numbers on a spreadsheet; it has nothing to do with the real economy of goods and services. It seeks rent, not well-being.

    Because these very basic ideas are not present in western politics or economics, the highest degrees could be considered worthless.

    They're pretty good at mechanical things, but don't understand human beings.

  18. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to shaberon For This Post:

    AutumnW (9th November 2026), Bill Ryan (8th November 2026), Mike (8th November 2026), rgray222 (8th November 2026)

  19. Link to Post #10
    Canada Avalon Member Ernie Nemeth's Avatar
    Join Date
    25th January 2011
    Location
    Toronto
    Age
    68
    Posts
    6,161
    Thanks
    28,048
    Thanked 40,978 times in 5,887 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    What is being suggested is exactly the thing I rebel against.

    I do not see eye to eye with anyone, whatever they decree I resist, even if "for my own good".

    I'd rather a despot rule than the "woke" crowd. The "woke" are a curse to all freedom loving people. A despot can be bargained with and many loopholes exist to disappear in the chaos.

    But once the liberals get power, their "righteousness" becomes a green light for atrocities against their opponents.
    Liberals and "woke" are cruel and vindictive - and their policies reflect that basic fundamental bent.
    Liberals are absolutists. Thus their "Big Tent" politics.
    Everyone is welcome, except the out-group, of course.
    And the out-group deserves everything vile and reprehensible.

    I believe China devised the best solution for these out-group evil doers. Murder them all!
    Then there is only the in-group left, and everything is rosy. What a great society they have, the liberals tell us, they all work as one!
    Sure they do. They eliminated all opposition generations ago...

    Please, before you implement a "one world government" of altruists, please, please, leave a place for those that want nothing at all to do with such an "utopia". It is a silly idea.

    Like Shaberon says, "they" don't understand human beings. "They" I would change to "we". It is the human condition that makes us as we are. Utopia awaits us on the other side. Have some patience. It's coming for us all in due time...
    Empty your mind, be formless, shapeless — like water...Now water can flow or it can crash. Be water, my friend. Bruce Lee

    Free will can only be as free as the mind that conceives it.

  20. The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to Ernie Nemeth For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (8th November 2026), Mike (8th November 2026), rgray222 (8th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (8th November 2026)

  21. Link to Post #11
    United States Administrator Sue (Ayt)'s Avatar
    Join Date
    23rd December 2016
    Language
    English
    Posts
    3,849
    Thanks
    39,705
    Thanked 27,774 times in 3,543 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by Ernie Nemeth (here)

    Murder them all!
    Then there is only the in-group left, and everything is rosy.
    Except that never seems to work in the long-run.

    It's my observation that groups that are united mainly in hate eventually turn on each other and split into smaller and smaller seething factions.
    "We're all bozos on this bus"

  22. The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to Sue (Ayt) For This Post:

    AutumnW (9th November 2026), Bill Ryan (8th November 2026), Ernie Nemeth (8th November 2026), Mike (8th November 2026), rgray222 (8th November 2026)

  23. Link to Post #12
    Avalon Member rgray222's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th September 2010
    Language
    English
    Posts
    3,772
    Thanks
    15,124
    Thanked 34,473 times in 3,661 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by Michi (here)
    Well - this video portrays drastic measures and I am not certain, if this is the only or perfect state. For example, the above video doesn't touch on nature and animals. So - how would that be integrated and how about those (like Bill) who prefer a life in nature - in some distance to overcrowded cities.
    I would subscribe to a meritocracy system and to have highly educated councils who actually advance the society and such councils must inherently self-correct with quality control.
    Citizens also actively participate in that quality control. (Perhaps similar to open source models.)
    Chasing perfection is foolish; it will never be attained. Chasing excellence is a much better idea
    Let me answer the question of how Bill or Ernie would fare in such a system. I don't think they would fare very well; they would be eliminated.

    Quote Posted by shaberon (here)
    When referring to the West, generally, it is inherently and permanently flawed, because it is just oligarchy.
    I don't disagree that the West is inherently flawed. Still, for my money, it is far less flawed than Russia or China; they are single-party authoritarian oligarchies where political power is concentrated in small elite groups of mostly corrupt people rather than distributed democratically. In the case of China, it is an exceptionally dangerous oligarchy that is comprised of high-ranking members of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), including the Politburo and its Standing Committee, who monopolize control over the government, military, and economy. And to think they are building nuclear weapons at a pace to be on par with Russia and the USA by the mid-2030s. China is spiralling down the rabbit hole of madness, and no one takes notice; they are all beguiled by rapid modernization and the temporarily improved quality of life for its citizens. Be entranced with China at your own risk.


    The bottom line is that we need to change the way the world is governed. Allowing one human to control all the power in any country is pure lunacy. We need to do away with Presidents, Prime Ministers and the almighty "Supreme leaders" and start governing with groups of elders that rotate out of these committees every three to five years.

  24. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to rgray222 For This Post:

    Bill Ryan (8th November 2026), cascadian (9th November 2026), Ernie Nemeth (8th November 2026), Michi (9th November 2026), Mike (8th November 2026), Sue (Ayt) (8th November 2026)

  25. Link to Post #13
    United States Avalon Member Mike's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th January 2011
    Location
    journeying to the end of the night
    Age
    49
    Posts
    6,963
    Thanks
    43,182
    Thanked 61,888 times in 6,873 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by shaberon (here)
    When referring to the west, generally, it is inherently and permanently flawed, because it is just oligarchy.

    Everything is inherently and permanently flawed. And the whole world is oligarchal.

    But the driving force of the west, or capitalism in particular, is competence and cooperation. Not power and greed. It's self-evident. We know this because if it wasn't true everything would collapse right this instant.

    It's beyond ridiculous to make the assumption that hierarchies in functioning western democracies are primarily based on tyranny and greed. It's the sort of embarrassing cliche you'd expect from a clever ten year old, and yet it's repeated ad nauseam by grown adults who should really know better. Consider a big western city (or even a small one), and all the hard infrastructure. Consider all the structures required to operate it, like transportation, roads, bridges, railways, airports, sanitation, water supply, energy grids, telecommunication networks etc. Consider the endless maintenance.

    Jesus man, think about the precise schedule the buses maintain. Consider the architecture of the skyscrapers! And all the institutional systems that maintain health and safety and cultural standards (including schools and universities, healthcare facilities, legal/financial systems, and government admin, and so on). Then there's the critical infrastructure - power plants, water treatment facilities etc. It's all a bloody miracle.

    And the people that build and maintain that stuff are paid very well. They have a high standard of living in the west. They enjoy law and order for the most part. They possess civil liberties, the presumption of innocence, freedom of thought and expression, freedom of speech, freedom of religion, due process, private property, and personal autonomy.. at least in the U.S. anyway. These things are all miracles! And took loads of blood and toil and time to achieve. It's so low resolution and ungrateful to dismiss it so arrogantly.

    Westerners participate in electing their leaders. They enjoy more wealth and freedom than any other place in any other time in human history. People in the west fundamentally cooperate with each other; if it was just greed and corruption and oligarchy none of this stuff would be possible. It's all highly ordered and coherent because it runs primarily on competence and cooperation, not power. Nothing could be more obvious.

    The west ended slavery. And since 1990 capitalism has lifted more than 1 billion people out of extreme poverty. But it's just oligarchy I guess.

    Of course corruption and greed exist here, but it exists everywhere. You may not be able to join the oligarchal ranks, but you still have the opportunity to be obscenely wealthy. Or at the very least, very comfortable. All while enjoying civil liberties and freedoms sorely lacking in other parts of the world.
    Last edited by Mike; 9th November 2026 at 17:05.

  26. The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Mike For This Post:

    Ernie Nemeth (9th November 2026), Michi (9th November 2026), rgray222 (9th November 2026)

  27. Link to Post #14
    Canada Avalon Member
    Join Date
    4th November 2012
    Posts
    3,387
    Thanks
    7,136
    Thanked 15,178 times in 3,035 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Can't get pics to load.
    Last edited by AutumnW; 9th November 2026 at 04:31. Reason: Cant get pics to load

  28. The Following User Says Thank You to AutumnW For This Post:

    Mike (9th November 2026)

  29. Link to Post #15
    United States Avalon Member Mike's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th January 2011
    Location
    journeying to the end of the night
    Age
    49
    Posts
    6,963
    Thanks
    43,182
    Thanked 61,888 times in 6,873 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by AutumnW (here)
    Can't get pics to load.
    Edit: you've ruined my little quip with your post edit, and I've had to delete it, and I resent you for it

    Go on, try again. But the irony effect has been ruined, at least for me
    Last edited by Mike; 9th November 2026 at 04:37.

  30. Link to Post #16
    Canada Avalon Member
    Join Date
    4th November 2012
    Posts
    3,387
    Thanks
    7,136
    Thanked 15,178 times in 3,035 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by Mike (here)
    Quote Posted by shaberon (here)
    When referring to the west, generally, it is inherently and permanently flawed, because it is just oligarchy.

    Everything is inherently and permanently flawed. And the whole world is oligarchal.

    But the driving force of the west, or capitalism in particular, is competence. Not power and greed. It's self-evident. We know this because if it wasn't true everything would collapse right this instant.

    It's beyond ridiculous to make the assumption that hierarchies in functioning western democracies are primarily based on tyranny and greed. It's the sort of embarrassing cliche you'd expect from a clever ten year old, and yet it's repeated ad nauseam by grown adults who should really know better. Consider a big western city (or even a small one), and all the hard infrastructure. Consider all the structures required to operate it, like transportation, roads, bridges, railways, airports, sanitation, water supply, energy grids, telecommunication networks etc. Consider the endless maintenance.

    Jesus man, think about the precise schedule the buses maintain. Consider the architecture of the skyscrapers! And all the institutional systems that maintain health and safety and cultural standards (including schools and universities, healthcare facilities, legal/financial systems, and government admin, and so on). Then there's the critical infrastructure - power plants, water treatment facilities etc. It's all a bloody miracle.

    And the people that build and maintain that stuff are paid very well. They have a high standard of living in the west. They enjoy law and order for the most part. They possess civil liberties, the presumption of innocence, freedom of thought and expression, freedom of speech, freedom of religion, due process, private property, and personal autonomy.. at least in the U.S. anyway. These things are all miracles! And took loads of blood and toil and time to achieve. It's so low resolution and ungrateful to dismiss it so arrogantly.

    Westerners participate in electing their leaders. They enjoy more wealth and freedom than any other place in any other time in human history. People in the west fundamentally cooperate with each other; if it was just greed and corruption and oligarchy none of this stuff would be possible. It's all highly ordered and coherent because it runs primarily on competence, not power. Nothing could be more obvious.

    The west ended slavery. And since 1990 capitalism has lifted more than 1 billion people out of extreme poverty. But it's just oligarchy I guess.

    Of course corruption and greed exist here, but it exists everywhere. You may not be able to join the oligarchal ranks, but you still have the opportunity to be obscenely wealthy. Or at the very least, very comfortable. All while enjoying civil liberties and freedoms sorely lacking in other parts of the world.
    "Competence"
    https://247wallst.com/special-report...e-last-decade/

    This doesn't cover banking products, like mortgage backed security fiasco that nearly bankrupted the US a few decades ago. Not to mention, dot com collapse, telecom failure, etc..etc.. Yeah, that sweet sweet competence.

  31. The Following User Says Thank You to AutumnW For This Post:

    Mike (9th November 2026)

  32. Link to Post #17
    United States Avalon Member Mike's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th January 2011
    Location
    journeying to the end of the night
    Age
    49
    Posts
    6,963
    Thanks
    43,182
    Thanked 61,888 times in 6,873 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by AutumnW (here)
    Quote Posted by Mike (here)
    Quote Posted by shaberon (here)
    When referring to the west, generally, it is inherently and permanently flawed, because it is just oligarchy.

    Everything is inherently and permanently flawed. And the whole world is oligarchal.

    But the driving force of the west, or capitalism in particular, is competence. Not power and greed. It's self-evident. We know this because if it wasn't true everything would collapse right this instant.

    It's beyond ridiculous to make the assumption that hierarchies in functioning western democracies are primarily based on tyranny and greed. It's the sort of embarrassing cliche you'd expect from a clever ten year old, and yet it's repeated ad nauseam by grown adults who should really know better. Consider a big western city (or even a small one), and all the hard infrastructure. Consider all the structures required to operate it, like transportation, roads, bridges, railways, airports, sanitation, water supply, energy grids, telecommunication networks etc. Consider the endless maintenance.

    Jesus man, think about the precise schedule the buses maintain. Consider the architecture of the skyscrapers! And all the institutional systems that maintain health and safety and cultural standards (including schools and universities, healthcare facilities, legal/financial systems, and government admin, and so on). Then there's the critical infrastructure - power plants, water treatment facilities etc. It's all a bloody miracle.

    And the people that build and maintain that stuff are paid very well. They have a high standard of living in the west. They enjoy law and order for the most part. They possess civil liberties, the presumption of innocence, freedom of thought and expression, freedom of speech, freedom of religion, due process, private property, and personal autonomy.. at least in the U.S. anyway. These things are all miracles! And took loads of blood and toil and time to achieve. It's so low resolution and ungrateful to dismiss it so arrogantly.

    Westerners participate in electing their leaders. They enjoy more wealth and freedom than any other place in any other time in human history. People in the west fundamentally cooperate with each other; if it was just greed and corruption and oligarchy none of this stuff would be possible. It's all highly ordered and coherent because it runs primarily on competence, not power. Nothing could be more obvious.

    The west ended slavery. And since 1990 capitalism has lifted more than 1 billion people out of extreme poverty. But it's just oligarchy I guess.

    Of course corruption and greed exist here, but it exists everywhere. You may not be able to join the oligarchal ranks, but you still have the opportunity to be obscenely wealthy. Or at the very least, very comfortable. All while enjoying civil liberties and freedoms sorely lacking in other parts of the world.
    "Competence"
    https://247wallst.com/special-report...e-last-decade/

    This doesn't cover banking products, like mortgage backed security fiasco that nearly bankrupted the US a few decades ago. Not to mention, dot com collapse, telecom failure, etc..etc.. Yeah, that sweet sweet competence.

    Yeah, so what?

    It's a high wire act. This sh!t will happen.

    It "nearly" bankrupted the US. But it didn't.

    We're still here. Still dominating.

  33. The Following User Says Thank You to Mike For This Post:

    rgray222 (10th November 2026)

  34. Link to Post #18
    Canada Avalon Member
    Join Date
    4th November 2012
    Posts
    3,387
    Thanks
    7,136
    Thanked 15,178 times in 3,035 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    It didn't bankrupt the US or cause a complete financial meltdown because government bailed out the banks. Sounds kind of "Communist" to me, Mike.

  35. The Following User Says Thank You to AutumnW For This Post:

    Mike (9th November 2026)

  36. Link to Post #19
    United States Avalon Member Mike's Avatar
    Join Date
    24th January 2011
    Location
    journeying to the end of the night
    Age
    49
    Posts
    6,963
    Thanks
    43,182
    Thanked 61,888 times in 6,873 posts

    Default Re: The Ethos of the New State

    Quote Posted by AutumnW (here)
    It didn't bankrupt the US or cause a complete financial meltdown because government bailed out the banks. Sounds kind of "Communist" to me, Mike.

    Jess, the west includes Canada too, remember?

    Help me make the argument, and we can bitch at each other in another thread.


+ Reply to Thread

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts